Izzy

Mackenzie Davis

Agatha Benson

Alia Shawkat

Virginia

Carrie Coon

Roger

Alex Russell

Walt

Haley Joel Osment

George

Keith Stanfield

Mary

Annie Potts

Gypsy

Salme Geransar

Young Izzy

Ryan Simpkins

Dick

Brandon T. Jackson

Ellen Wexler

Lauren Miller

Mrs. Percy

Melinda McGraw

Bennett

Rob Huebel

Whitney

Sarah Goldberg

Rabbit

Kyle Kinane

Leo

Luka Jones

Casey

Meghan Lennox

Tom

Sheldon Bailey

The Woman in the Field

Dolly Wells

Ugly Sweater Girl

Michelle Haro

Engagement party guest

Suzanne LaChasse

Grey-haired Woman

Marcia Ann Burrs

Jogger

Robyn Clark

Bartender

Bobby Lamont

Engagement party guest

Rebecca Kessler

Ugly Sweater Guy

Johnny Otto

Andy Wexler

Matt Riker

Engagement party guest

Robert Santi

Theatre Attendee

Ty Hubbard

Waiter

PeterPaul Shaker

Ugly Sweater party guest

Andrea Finlayson

Theater Patron

India Mynatt

Engagement party guest

Leonard Cataudella

Ugly sweater party guest

Spenser Genesy

Engagement party guest

Rebecca Berry

Ugly Sweater party guest

Joshua Carpenter

Engagement party guest

Sara Werner

Ugly Sweater party guest

Evan Rossman

Engagement party guest

Blaire Strong

Engagement party guest

Sarah Furniss