Lizzie Borden

Chloë Sevigny

Bridget "Maggie" Sullivan

Kristen Stewart

Andrew Borden

Jamey Sheridan

Abby Borden

Fiona Shaw

Emma Borden

Kim Dickens

John Morse

Denis O'Hare

Andrew Jennings

Jeff Perry

Deputy Fleet

Jody Matzer

William Henry Moody

Jay Huguley

Susan Gilbert

Tara Ochs

Dr. Bowen

Daniel Wachs

Jury Foreman

Darin Cooper

Judge Blaisdell

Roscoe Sandlin

Tenement Man

Jeremy Sykes

Marshall Hilliard

Don Henderson Baker

Tenant

Ivylyn Nickel

Mrs. Brayton

Laura Whyte

Professor Wood

Tom Thon

Irish Townsman

Zachary Kyle Musten

Ashton Tatum

Matron

Katharine Harrington

Elgin Lee

New Housemaid

Vivian Majkowski

Scott R. Phillips

Police Man

Thomas Mark Higgins