Sister Mary

Molly C. Quinn

Benjamin

Jake Horowitz

Paul Satchimo

Sean Gunn

Father Black

Chris Browning

Sister Agnes

Hayley McFarland

Sister Ruth

Rachel True

Father Donaghue

Ben Hall

Sister Honey

Zandy Hartig

Mother Superior

Mary Buss

Earl

Bruce Davis

Father Exley

Van Quattro

Curly

Chris Sullivan

Father Cappa

Chris Freihofer

Comedy Club Patron (uncredited)

Lorri Bohnert

Wanda

Ginger Gilmartin

Sister Margaret

Cait Brasel

Sister McConnell

Cheryl McConnell

Pete

Jacob Ryan Snovel

Sister Mawd

Azrial Greene

Sister Gertrude

Rita Scranton

Evelyn

Thashana McQuiston

Grocery Store Shopper /Comedy Club Patron

Garrett O'Brien

Waitress 3

Heather Siess

The Bishop

Ron Sutor

Diner patron

Beth M. Alonso

Bar Patron

Jay North

Pedro

Alex Sánchez