William H. 'Billy the Kid' Bonney

Johnny Mack Brown

Deputy Sheriff Pat Garrett

Wallace Beery

Claire Randall

Kay Johnson

Swenson

Karl Dane

John W. Tunston

Wyndham Standing

Mc Sween

Russell Simpson

Mrs. McSween

Blanche Frederici

Mrs. McSween

Blanche Friderici

Old Stuff

Roscoe Ates

Bob Ballinger

Warner Richmond

William P. Donovan

James A. Marcus

Bob Ballinger

Warner P. Richmond

Hatfield

Nelson McDowell

Man at Bar

King Vidor

Dick Brewer

Jack Carlyle

Butterworth

John Beck

Santiago

Chris-Pin Martin

Nicky Whoosiz

Marguerita Padula

Mrs. Hatfield

Aggie Herring

Henchman Polka Dot (uncredited)

Hank Bell

Cowhand (uncredited)

Buck Bucko

Posseman (uncredited)

Roy Bucko

Cowhand (uncredited)

Bob Card

Henchman Joe (uncredited)

Frank Ellis

Bert Grant (uncredited)

Frank Hagney

Santiago's Mother (uncredited)

Soledad Jiménez

Townsman (uncredited)

Bud McClure

Homesteader Mrs. Foster (uncredited)

Sarah Padden

General Lew Wallace (uncredited)

Frank Reicher

Homesteader Mr. Foster (uncredited)

Carl Stockdale

Outlaw (uncredited)

Blackjack Ward