Katherine
Hilarie Burton
Caleb
Tyler Hilton
Lilly
Markie Post
Mr. Greenhall
Randy Travis
Papa Noel
Edward Asner
Zac
Brody Rose
Sienna
Ariana Neal
Bryce
Cannon Bosarge
Josh
Griff Furst
Young Caleb
Colin Bates
Park Ranger Beth
Samantha Beaulieu
Flashback Kid
Jacob Etter
Local Woman
Odessa Feaster
Janelle
Dana Gourrier
Kathryn's Assistant
Leticia Jimenez
Young Katherine
Mary Katherine Oglesby
Pageant Attendee
Lisa Raziano
Receptionist
Angela M. Thomas
Store Patron (uncredited)
Allen Boudreaux
Office Worker (uncredited)
John C. Coffman
Bonfire Goer (uncredited)
Jay Florsheim
Extra (uncredited)
Bria Hobgood
Bonfire Goer (uncredited)
Tommy Sheppard