Jesus Christ

Jonathan Bennett

American Lena

Marya Sea Kaminski

Tamara

Lea DeLaria

American Potato

Tyler Bocock

John

Dan Lauria

Nina Ivanovna

Lauren Tewes

Young Lena

Sera Barbieri

Mandy

Sophia Mitri Schloss

American Teacher

Alycia Delmore

Russian Potato

Hersh Powers

Prisoner

Devin Bannon

Video Store Clerk

Jordan Iosua Taylor

Fedia

Forrest Campbell

Young Prisoner

Michael Monicatti

Sunday School Teacher

Annette Toutonghi

Virgin Mary

Lady Rizo

Russian Teacher

Sarah Rudinoff

Carrie

Nicole Santora

Young John

James Grixoni

Sunday School Teacher

Amy Love

Bus Eavesdropper

Alice Bridgforth

Potato's Lover

Cameron Lee Price

Drew Highlands

Vova

Jule Johnson

Max Willoughby

Fantasy Husband

L. Gabriel Gonda

Quinlan Corbett

Potato's Lover

Nick Sage Palmieri

Aaron Jin

John's First Wife

Darlene Sellers

Potato's Lover

Dylan Smith

Alexandra Tavares

Henry DiStefano

Potato's Father

Michael Place

Paul Budraitis

Hisam Goueli

Clyde Petersen

Ruby Mimosa

Rebecca M. Davis

Female Pastor

Rebecca Davis