Father Robert Koesler

Donald Sutherland

Father Ted Nabors

Charles Durning

Lieutenant Koznicki

Josef Sommer

Pat Lennon

Belinda Bauer

Robert Javison

James Murtaugh

Mrs. Washington

Leila Danette

Detective Harris

John Danelle

Father Edward Killeen

Addison Powell

Sister Ann Vania

Kathleen Tolan

Detective Fallon

Tom Mardirosian

Irene Jimenez

Anita Barone

Father Skiarski

Rex Everhart

Officer Knight

Jihmi Kennedy

Sister Mary Martyrs

Anna Minot

Sophie

Lupe Ontiveros

Father Max

Mark Margolis

Brainard

Roger Angelini

Sister Grace

B. Constance Barry

Newscaster

Doris Biscoe

Librarian

Sandy Broad

Altar Boy

Keith Brooks

Nancy Baldwin

Bethany Carpenter

Schommer

Joseph Conrad

Officer Mills

Richard Cottrell

Priest

Bruce Economou

Funeral Woman

Lilian Ferguson

Trupiano

Stefan Gierasch

Father Lord

Harold Hansen

Sister Magdala

Cordis Heard

Kane

Robert Heller

Passing Cop

Don Lessnau

Mrs. Jimenez

María López

Father Marek

Robert C. Maxwell

Coney Island Customer

Sheldon Miller

Listening Priest

Joel Nash

Patrolman Wozniak

Ed Oldani

Father Lasko

Burt Pearson

Father Dailey

Sam Pollack

Father O'Day

David Regal

Sergeant Ross

Ed Ruffalo

Father Harold Steele

Edward Seamon

Cathy Javison

Janet M. Smith

Father McNiff

Peter Van Norden

Mrs. Gates

Josephine Vassalo

Prioress

Jo Mullin White

Sister Vania's Beau

Dennis Wrosch

Driver

Jeffrey R. Dolan

Georgine Hall

Guest at Party (uncredited)

Michael Mili

Altar Boy (uncredited)

Jack White