Don Verdean

Sam Rockwell

Boaz

Jemaine Clement

Carol

Amy Ryan

Pastor Fontaine

Will Forte

Tony Lazarus

Danny McBride

Joylinda

Leslie Bibb

Poon-Yen

Stephen Park

Dr. Stanley

Sky Elobar

Church Elder

Michael Flynn

Israeli Police Officer

Yaniv Moyal

Gary

PJ Boudousque

Lab Tech

Jared Shipley

Officer Schmidt

Jake Van Wagoner

Tourist

Logan Rogan

Shem

Stelios Xanthos

Antique Store Owner

Pete Rockwell

Security Guard

Harry Bonner

Dad

Mitchell Hall

Reporter #1

Brent Hunsaker

Sarah (uncredited)

Deborah Lee Douglas

Reporter #2

Nicea Degering

Rude Teen (uncredited)

Connor Williams

Helicopter Pilot

Justin Chapman

Lecture Listener (uncredited)

Ricky Egan

Reporter (uncredited)

Jeremy Warner

Angel Martinez