Adult Mickey

Ray Liotta

Roger

Rory Culkin

Poppy

Seymour Cassel

Mickey

Trevor Morgan

Dr. Stuart

Michael O'Keefe

Kelly

Tania Raymonde

Marilyn

Lauren Holly

Andrew Brynarski

Jamie

Willa Holland

Officer L.

Keith David

Deputy Fryman

Lori Petty

Adult Roger

Jay Karnes

Young Roger

Nicholas Brady

Chuck Ireland

M. Emmet Walsh

Baseball Coach

Scott Aaronson

Young MIckey

Blake Woodyard

Bobby

Matt Abshire

Short Order Cook

Kevin Gage

Dad

Michael R. Aubele

Danny

Drake Kemper

Gang Member

Andrew Bryniarski

Sally waitress

Alisa Schulz

Dr. Boogie

Ricardo Antonio Chavira

Admittance Nurse

Mercedes Connor

Principal Motley

Cris D'Annunzio

Gang Member

Dan Fastuca

The Minister

Michael Govia

ER Doctor

Ryan R. Johnson

Maddy Straka

Madison Lanesey

Pirates Fan

Meritt Latimore

Short Order Cook

Louis Lombardi

Young Baseball Player

Zander Lyons

Mets Catcher

Ryan March

Coach Johnson

Christopher May

Jr. Nurse K. Copland

Katie Piel

Umpire

Jax Pyle

Bobby Straka

Patrick Sebes

Catcher

Max Van Ville

Gang Leader

Zakk Wylde

ER Doctor (uncredited)

Geoffrey Gould

Home Plate Umpire (uncredited)

Calvin Dean

First Base Coach (uncredited)

Bill Mikita

Pirates Fan (uncredited)

David Morse