Katherine

Christina Hendricks

Debra

Sienna Miller

Chris

Aaron Paul

Terry

Will Sasso

Bridget Callahan

Sky Ferreira

Peggy

Amy Madigan

Ray

Pat Healy

Young Jesse

Aidan McGraw

Tyler Hanrick

Alex Neustaedter

Det. Sergeant Morris

E. Roger Mitchell

Jesse

Aidan Fiske

Brett Tobeck

Kentucker Audley

Jesse (Age 1)

Alexander Joseph Wildes

Jesse (Age 1)

Maximus Thomas Wildes

Cindy

Katie Elinoff

Paul

Rene Cadet

Murph (Age 10)

Gavin Earle

Patrick (Age 8)

Kobi Polisky

Carol Hanrick

Adrianne Krstansky

Jenna Cunningham

Kelly Rose Golden

Detective O'Brien

Bates Wilder

Local News Reporter

Chet Harding

Mrs. Clancy

Gwen Callahan

Mrs. Caponi

Karen Elverson

Mrs. Hastings

Rosemary Mahoney

Brett's Wife

Maggie Castle

Professor Walters

Dennis Staroselsky

Murph (Age 16)

Tyler Wesley Parrish

Patrick - Age 14

Jack Brunault

Colleen

Maggie Budzyna

Aunt Dottie

Dottie Reid

Uncle Jack

Jack Reid

Paul Aaron

Priest

Christopher Hickey

Nursing Assistant #1

Rebecca Gibel

Nursing Assistant #2

Georgia Lyman

Shawna

Nancy Villone

Murph (Age 21)

Matt Merritt

Patrick (Age 18)

Logan Hallowell

Sarah

Sarah Amber Newcomb

Mrs. Coates

Dee Nelson

Derrick Daughter

Gillian Mariner Gordon

Mrs. Derrick

Rachel Singer

Man at the House (uncredited)

Joseph Oliveira

Search Party Member (uncredited)

Lexie Roth

Search Party Volunteer (uncredited)

Danielle Lyons

Police Officer (uncredited)

Michael Marchand

Search Party Member (uncredited)

Tom Mariano