Louis 'Lepke' Buchalter

Tony Curtis

Bernice Meyer

Anjanette Comer

Robert Kane

Michael Callan

Gurrah Shapiro

Warren Berlinger

Albert Anastasia

Gianni Russo

Mr. Meyer

Milton Berle

Charles 'Lucky' Luciano

Vic Tayback

Marion

Mary Wilcox

Little Augie

Jack Ackerman

Max Rubin

Louis Guss

Mama Meyer

Lillian Adams

Walter Winchell

Vaughn Meader

Gross

Albert Cole

Abe `Kid Twist' Reles

Zitto Kazann

Albert Tannenbaum

Simmy Bow

Schwartz

Johnny Silver

Judge

Russ Grieve

Mendy Weiss

J.S. Johnson

Bugsy Siegel

Clement von Franckenstein

Dutch Schultz

John Durren

Young Lepke

Barry Miller

Big Hesh

Jon Ian Jacobs

Skinny

Matt Greene

Thomas E. Dewey

Richard C. Adams

Butcher

Sam Solomon

Prostitute

Jeannine Brown

Gino

Raymond Cavaleri

J. Edgar Hoover

Edwin Fuller

Rabbi

Norman Pauker

Doorman

Chuck Hayward

First Detective

Wesley Lau

Mrs. Shea

Ida Mae McKenzie

Feldman

Jack Tesler

Policeman

T.J. Castronovo

Lin Phoo

Joseph Kim

Flapper (uncredited)

Jacqulin Cole

Young Gurrah

Casey Morgan

Detective

Jim Hayes

Reporter

Guy Christopher

Cantor

Marco Goldstein

Mr. Stern

Zachary Berger

Judge

Crane Jackson

Second Reporter

Buck Young

Policeman

Thomas Castranova

Sarah

Robin Chesler

Violinist

Josef Behrens

Erwin Fuller

Ken Del Conte

Ben Freedman

Dick Winslow

Michael Masters

Sy Kramer

Vincent Di Paolo