Bob the Tomato / Jimmy Gourd / Percy Pea / Octavious (Mr. Lunt) / Captain (Pa Grape) / Pastor (George) (voice)

Phil Vischer

Larry the Cucumber / Dad Carrot / Jean Claude Pea (voice)

Mike Nawrocki

Amy Grant

Nicholas (voice)

Gigi Abraham

Junior Asparagus (voice)

Lisa Vischer

Gustav / Epiphanus (voice)

Alan Lee

Sister Claire (Petunia Rhubarb) (voice)

Cydney Trent

Laura Carrot (voice)

Megan Murphy

Tona (voice)

Keri Pisapia

Little Drummer Boy (voice)

Kurt Heinecke

Poor Father (voice)

J. Chris Wall

Extras (voice)

Brian Roberts

Extras (voice)

Brian K. Roberts

Extras (voice)

Joe Spadaford

Extras (voice)

Sarah Vorhees Wendel