Agent Peccant

Ant

Sister Mary Ignatius

Diane Keaton

Gary Sullivan

Brian Benben

Mark Rima

James Vallo

Chris Riant

Shawn Quinland

Farmer Jake

Bruce Vilanch

Aloysius Benheim

Wallace Langham

Older Nun

Judy Tenuta

Angela DiMarco

Laura San Giacomo

Chief Homer Bathos

Matthew Feeney

Philomena Rostovich

Jennifer Tilly

Detective Emma Sharp

Michelle Shields

Thomas

Max Morrow

Father O'Bleary

James Pusztay

Skeptical Husband

Martin Mull

Chad

Brent Corrigan

Ray

Z.D. Smith

Bitter Divorcee

Victoria Tennant

Tranny McTrannerson

Suzy Brack

Cynthia Johnson

Joanne Boland

Father Perdu

Eddie Huchro

Tony Cardonelli

John Davey

Elecktra Le Strange

Erin Muir

Deaf Woman

Joan Gregson

Skeptical Husband's Wife

Linda Kash

Truck Driver

B.J. Woodbury

Ellen

Jeanine Hill

Mrs. Cardonelli

Jocelyn Zucco

Young Philomena

Rebecca Brenner

Young Aloysius

Spencer Van Wyck

Young Gary

Michael Cameron

Young Angela

Chloe Randle-Reis

King Herod

Steven Taylor

Angel

Iaislinn Paul

Cynthia's Father

Larry Mannell

Cynthia's Mother

Deborah Tennant

Hunter Scott

Saintly Girl

Dana Fernald

Woman in Audience 1

Edie Inksetter

Woman in Audience 2

Mari Trainor

Woman in Audience 3

Colleen Williams

Attractive Man 1

Glen McDonald

Attractive Man 2

Mark Allan

Man in Audience 1

Paul MacFarlane