Holly Teller

Elisabeth Harnois

Sheriff Richards

Val Kilmer

Amber Richards

Diora Baird

Western Man / Jack Abel

William Sadler

Nathan Teller

Ryan Malgarini

Matt Caldwell

Bryan Lillis

Disheveled Man / Gene Bristol

Jack Erdie

Cameron Bronson

Ben Bledsoe

Mr. Blackburn

Rick Applegate

Hal

Bingo O'Malley

Michelle

Brandi Engel

Sheriff's Office Receptionist

Sharon Murray

Deputy Clark

Joshua Elijah Reese

Mrs. Morgan

Annie Kitral

Mr. Walker

Jeff Hochendoner

Female Riddle Child

KatiAna Davis

Leanne

Agnes Herrmann

Mr. Brody

Tommy Lafitte

Jersey Bowman

Bill Laing

Gabby Teller

Adrienne Wehr

Pool Player (uncredited)

Jackson Nunn