Stan Deen

Jared Harris

Nathan Williams

Nicholas Hamilton

Johnny Alecco

Will Price

Barney

Jamie Harris

Tina Baxter

Sasha Bhasin

Nate's Father

Tobias Segal

Deborah May

Kimberly S. Fairbanks

Henry V (voice)

Martin Jarvis

Barnaby

Brandon Miles

Officer Smits

Johnathan Davis

Judge

Daisy Galvis

Mother

Scottie DiGiacomo

Young Nathan

Banks Quinney

Linda

Elise Hudson

Gloria

Meredith Sullivan

Jen

Niva Patel

Orphan

Gwyneth Anne Trumbore

Young Woman Annabel

Shannon Destiny Ryan

Rona

Searra Sawka

Pastor's Daughter

Ava Wrubel

Carl

Sung Yoon

Sandy

Kiley Lotz

Noah

Cole Tristan Murphy

Blake

Chris James Boylan

Nanny Cole

Carol Florence

Terry

Rachel Poletick

Travis

Collin Roach

Cellmate

L. J. Moses

Older Woman

Kathy Patterson

Attorney

Lauren LoGiudice

Prison Guard

Ernest DiLullo Sr.

Neighbor

Kendra Mittermeyer

Orphan

Cole Flanders

Tom Friedman

Phillip Chorba

Mariam Baker

Susanne Sulby

Booking Officer

Vann Barrett

Jim Baxter

Joey Cabrera

Mrs. Feeney

Madalyn St. John

Principal Larson

Pat DeFusco

Lisa

Madeleine Garcia

Teacher

Brian Foreman

Nurse 1

Johny Walsh

High School Student

Nicolai Kabana

Grandpa Cole

Michael Harrah

Bruce

Sebastian Coates

Prison Guard

Derek Larthey

Track Teammate

AJ Rhoads

Mr. Sullivan

Stan Kang

Orphan

Evyn Flanders

Orphan

Lillian Haverty

Bobby

Hasan Mustafic

Paramedic #1

Chuck Pressler

Detective

Morris Davis

Theatre Student

Kylee Anne Agnello

High School Student

Sammy Lynne Toth

Carol

Emilyanne Cusato

Student / Party Girl

Lyndsey Bentham

Party Teen

Alexander Ramirez

Mrs. Sullivan

Lisa Sponaugle

Student

Cathy Ritter

Attorney

Rodney Jones

Track Meet Spectator

Madison Frye

Officer Spellen

Michael Jansen

Police Officer

Michael Thomas Ford

Viola

Nancy Marron-Asti

Student

Matt R Stover

Orphan

Safiyah Brown

Orphan

Gwendolyn Varley

Student

Luke Simons

Theater Student

Ashleigh Sites

High School Student

Cherie Klenieski

Track Meet Spectator

Alyssa Frye

Regina

Wendy Staton

Track Meet Parent

Steve 'Stevieweevie' Jones

Baker (uncredited)

Joseph Giambrone

Nurse (uncredited)

Gina Jun

Grocery Store Deli Personnel (uncredited)

Lois Sach

Parent (uncredited)

Tim R. Worley