Alex Malmquist

Cooper Raiff

Maggie Hill

Dylan Gelula

Mom

Amy Landecker

Jess

Olivia Welch

Sam

Logan Miller

Georgia

Abby Quinn

Sophia

Joy Sunday

DG

Ashley Padilla

Garrett

Tre Hall

Julia

Alina Patra

Timothy

Chinedu Unaka

Mason Birch

Nick Saso

Seb

Wyatt Whipple

Charlie

Juan Wood

Jeff

Andrew Hales

Caroline

Mallory Low

Scott

Adan Rocha

Nellie

Natalie Rousseau

Matt

Teddy Padilla

Jay

Adam Foster Ballard

Not Maggie

Tessa Hope Slovis

Dad

Mike Raiff

Guy with Knife (uncredited)

Chris Kleckner

Dancing College Student

Spencer Whaley

Professor Notkin (uncredited)

Jay Duplass

Jeremy (uncredited)

Harrison Callaghan

Emily (uncredited)

Ayo Edebiri

Professor Bittenbender (uncredited)

Grant Harling

Grace (uncredited)

Macey Isaacs

Girl #2 (uncredited)

Jenny Leiferman

Josh (uncredited)

Denny McAuliffe

Girl #1 (uncredited)

Bianca Pompa

Tyler (uncredited)

Colin McCalla

Monica (uncredited)

Leonora Pitts

Chandler's Father (uncredited)

Scott Pitts

Stage Actress (uncredited)

Melissa Stenger

Michelle (uncredited)

Eva Victor

Chandler (uncredited)

Will Youmans