Jack Huston

Kristoffer Polaha

Lucy Hardgrove

Bethany Joy Lenz

Claude Lancaster

Colton Little

Harold Balaban

Robert Picardo

Winston

Jonathan Frakes

Margaret

A.K. Benninghofen

Director

Mary Beth McDonough

Ava Hayward

Annabelle Borke

Peggy

Jennifer Cortese

William West

David Alexander

Michael Balaban

Tommy Cresswell

Becca

Caity Brewer

Security Guard

Jason Saucier

Sandra

Philena Gilmer

Head Angel

Alphie Hyorth

Charlie

Wes Brown

James's Father

Ray Fawley

Tree Lighting Patron

Bobbie Peterson

Gus

Ray Ficca

Present Day Tourist

Barbara Nuss Stiles

Waiter

Josh Yarusinsky

Lucy, Actress

Rachel Boston

Young boy at Christmas party

Zander Ash