Sheriff Dan Lee

Cotton Yancey

Webb Langston

Jeremy London

Joe Loftin

Chris Bosarge

Moses Loftin

Matt Story

Lavinia Loftin

Heather Fusari

John T

Creek Wilson

Preacher

William E. Harris

Doctor Larkin

Michael LaCour

Longino

Michael D. Anglin

Marion

Aspen Kennedy Wilson

Silas Loftin

Matthew R. Horton

Crawford Loftin

Britton Webb

Miles

Nic Roylance

Judge

Raymond Soutullo

Church-goer

Lamar Lott

Prisoner

Melvin Pittman

Jury Member

Damon Burks

James Sauls

Miles Donald

Church Girl

Katira Banks

Hiram

Kevin J. McGrath

Prison Guard

Rajko Scarabin

McNair

Dorsey Carson

Telegraph Operator

Tom Humbarger

Nurse

Mamie Davis

Daniels

Josh Priest

Saloon Girl

Krystal Sherrod

Hobbs

Matt Wymer

Jerome

Morgan Browning

Matt

Marlene Cupit

Joe Gang

Jake Milton

Mrs. Loftin

Dawn Streeck

Ambrose

Markeith Coleman

Warden

Tim Sherrod

Churchmember

Stephanie Davis Holmes

Church Member/Vigilante

Hugh Daniel Porter

Farmer

William Perkins

Vigilante

Terry Key

Vigilante

Beau Hale

Farmer's Wife

Nichole Henry

Joe Gang

Kelly Porter

Joe's Youngest Daughter

Caroline Quin

Joe's Oldest Daughter

Olivia Quin

David Stevens

Huddleston

Nicholas Ryan Bain

Bart

Bart Massey

Sandy

Calvin L. Franklin

Blacksmith/Fighter

Travis Mills