Morgan Quinn

Holland Roden

Gabe DeLuca

Matthew Daddario

Uncle Tommy

Joe Pantoliano

Frank DeLuca

Steve Schirripa

Joanne Quinn

Tracy Pollan

Ricki DeLuca

Caroline Aaron

Chris Brown

Chris Brown

Cathy

Patti Murin

Jeremy

Patrick Mulvey

Santa Claus

Abraham Benrubi

Trish

Mariand Torres

Mia

Eve Gordon

Angela

Meghann Garmany

Barista

Kristopher Charles

Cyndi Claus

Mary Stout

Nurse Alice

Carmen Ruby Floyd

Bartender (Cameo)

Andrew W. Walker

Dale

Charlie McElveen

Post Office Worker

Robert Bozek

Halftime Announcer

Luke Russert

Ava

Luciana VanDette

Scott Norwood

Scott Norwood

Thurman Thomas

Thurman Thomas

Steve Tasker

Steve Tasker

Sean McDermott

Sean McDermott

Damar Hamlin

Damar Hamlin

Dion Dawkins

Dion Dawkins

Deena (Cameo)

Hunter King

John (Cameo)

Tyler Hynes

Andre Reed

Andre Reed

Young Morgan (Uncredited)

Nell Bichler

Featured Bills Fan (Uncredited)

Christine Hulton

Buffalo Bills Fan (Uncredited)

Christopher Fortin

Bills Fan (Uncredited)

Joseph Damiano

Bills Fan (Uncredited)

Joshua Cole

Tailgator (Uncredited)

Taylor Clark

Pedestrian / Caroler (Uncredited)

Jill Mack

Canalside Pedestrian (Uncredited)

Liz Cameron

Ashley Szczerbacki

Tailgater/Neighborhood Pedestrian (Uncredited)

Heather Benson