Dallas Cowboys Cheerleader Melissa Rycroft became a familiar face in reality TV when she appeared on the 13th season of the popular series The Bachelor in 2008. She was selected the winner at the end of the season, but Bachelor Jason Mesnick then changed his mind and broke up with Rycroft in favor of runner-up Molly Malaney. Rycroft then joined the cast of Dancing with the Stars in 2009 just before the eighth season premiere, stepping in to replace Nancy O'Dell, who withdrew due to injury.