Himself - Host
Nick Offerman
Herself - Host
Amy Poehler
Herself - Judge
Dayna Isom Johnson
Himself - Judge
Simon Doonan
Jimmy DiResta
Contestant
Joanna Gick
Contestant
Amber Kemp Gerstel
Contestant
Billy Kheel
Contestant
Robert Mahar
Contestant
Khiem Nguyen
Contestant
Nicole Sweeney
Contestant
Jemma Olson
Contestant
Jeffery Rudell