Quentin Coldwater

Jason Ralph

Julia Wicker

Stella Maeve

Alice Quinn

Olivia Taylor Dudley

Eliot Waugh

Hale Appleman

William "Penny" Adiyodi

Arjun Gupta

Margo Hanson

Summer Bishil

Kady Orloff-Diaz

Jade Tailor

Marina Andrieski

Kacey Rohl

Dean Fogg

Rick Worthy

Richard

Mackenzie Astin

Victoria

Hannah Levien

Fen

Brittany Curran

Josh Hoberman

Trevor Einhorn

Tick Pickwick

Rizwan Manji

Rafe

Sergio Osuna

George

Oliver Bell

Pete

David Call

Professor Lipson

Keegan Connor Tracy

Todd

Adam DiMarco

The Beast

Charles Mesure

Gillen

Zahf Paroo

Fairy Queen

Candis Cayne

Heloise

Miranda Edwards

Harriet

Marlee Matlin

Benedict Pickwick

Harvey Guillén

Gavin

Daniel Nemes

Jane Chatwin

Rose Liston

Eliza / Jane Chatwin

Esmé Bianco

Healer Faye

Valerie Tian

Prof. Pearl Sunderland

Anne Dudek

Silver

Bobbi Charlton

Menolly / Menially

Fiona Hogan

Our Lady Underground

Garcelle Beauvais

Prince Ess

Arlen Escarpeta

Fray

Madeleine Arthur

Irene McAllistair

Jaime Ray Newman

Christopher Plover

Charles Shaughnessy

Plum Chatwin / Merritt

Riann Steele

The Librarian / Zelda

Mageina Tovah