Various

Tim Heidecker

Various

Eric Wareheim

Announcer (voice) / Cinco Announcer (voice) / Various

Bob Odenkirk

Guest Star

Fred Willard

Guest Star

Frank Stallone

Guest Star

Zach Galifianakis

Pall Willeaux / Will Grello / Dr. Reid Tamaranda

Will Forte

Dr. Steve Brule

John C. Reilly

Guest Star

Alan Thicke

Guest Star

Josh Groban

Guest Star

Tommy Wisseau

Self / Pep Pep / Old Office Temp

Richard Dunn

Guest Star

Larry Miller

Self

David Liebe Hart

Guest Star

Scott Thompson

Guest Star

David Wain

Self

James Quall

Announcer (voice) / Tiny Hats Announcer (voice) / Gravy Robbers Announcer

Bill A. Jones

Self / —

Ben Hur

Pierre / Bride's Parents

Ron Austar

Self / Employee / Reenactment Eric

Jon Mugar

Self / Lindsay Porch / Chanter

Bob Druwing

Self / Pastor / Gravy Robber Trainee

Warren Stearns

Self / Prance Stuard / Crystal Shyps Actor

Ron Stark

Kaz / Birthday Party Guest / Tiny Hat Wearer

Kazu Nagahama

Seminar Student / Joey Heidecker

Joey Brander

Cinco Spokesman / Blind Man / Video Match Client

Rainn Wilson

Self / Sit On You Guy / Sit on You Guy

Palmer Scott

Self / Game Player

Tanese Gray

Kent / Self

Bob Ross