The Guy

Ben Sinclair

Faruq Moustafa

Rajeev Pahuja

Herself

Rachel Comey

Bradley

Michael Braun

Guest Star

Crystal Bock

Annie

Kether Donohue

Female Coach

Ashlie Atkinson

Guest Star

Carlen Altman

Guest Star

Lyman Chen

Joel

Fred Berman

Guest Star

Molly Camp

Guest Star

Jordan Dean

Guest Star

Nat Cassidy

Upstairs Neighbor

Ethan T. Berlin

Molly

Molly Knefel

Man on train

Mark Gessner

Patrick

Michael Cyril Creighton

Cashier

Victor Almanzar

Himself

Batman

Co-worker

Sara Cicilian

Guest Star

Katie Hartman

Lionel

Dyllon Burnside

Australian

Melissa Loseby

Shira

Bettina Bilger

Neighbor

Florence Blake

Hopeful Stomper #1

Keely Beirne

Guest Star

John Conroy

Guest Star

Bridget Moloney

Leader

Steve Cirbus

Hannibal

Hannibal Buress

Corey

Steven Boyer

Brenna

Brenna Palughi

Mark

Kyle Harris

Guest Star

Max Jenkins

Kabir

Azhar Khan

Ellen

Birgit Huppuch

Evan

Avery Monsen

Jackie

Joanna Bradley

Dad

T.J. Kenneally

Naomi

Sue Jean Kim

Mrs. Watkins

Natalie Carter

Guest Star

Anna Rose Hopkins

Hank

Hank Chen

Mom with Stroller

Victoria Haynes

Reagan

Hannah Bos

Birder #1

Marcella Roy

The Cypriot

Alex Malaos

Wayne

John Early

Guest Star

John Peery

Victor

Chris McKinney

Audition Room Stomper #4

Chris Clay

Guest Star

Theodore Bouloukos

Derek

Luke Forbes

Autumn

Kathryn Boswell

Mormon

Matthew Minor

Heidi

Greta Lee

Chad

Chris Roberti

Clive

Dan Sickles

Birder #2

Rob Leo Roy

Guest Star

Dawn Luebbe

Van Stoner

Kate Thulin

Danielle

Kate Dearing

Guest Star

Candace Thompson

Becky

Katja Blichfeld

Isabel

Leah Rudick

Mr. Softee

J. Bernard Calloway

Guest Star

Heléne Yorke

Guest Star

Kyle Dean Massey

Guest Star

Preston Sadleir

Mindy

Jenny Fellner

Andrew

William Jackson Harper

Daikeen

Jason Cruz

Guest Star

Abdullah 'The Kid' Saeed

Guest Star

Alexandra Gjerpen

Jeanette

Beth Hoyt

Teacher #1

Anais Fifer

Miriam

Deborah Offner

Birder #3

Keith Shaw

Bill

Steven Mark Friedman

Arty Lesbian #2

Emily Donahoe

Guest Star

Henry Zebrowski

Guest Star

Clare McNulty

Another Dealer

Michelle Cameron

Maurice

Benjamin Thys

Neighbor

John Keating

Ruth

Jennifer Smith

Saul

Lee Wilkof

Ms. Farad

Jenn Harris

Claire

Tonya Glanz

Rachel

Jessica Rothe

Hasidic Man

Elli

Diabetic Man

Zach Cherry

Jaden

Jade Eshete

Colin

Dan Stevens

Birder #4

Andre Ward

Rob

Michael Guagno

Sales Clerk

Bryan Langlitz

Shaquille

Jared Kemp

Female Teacher

Siri Hellerman

Audition Room Stomper #4

Anthony Festa