Richard Slate

Richard Speight Jr.

Rob Bennett

Rob Benedict

The Vegas Selfie Fan

Sarah Chang

Justin Angles

Jensen Ackles

Kent O'Grady

Josh Meyers

Matt Cochran

Matt Cohen

The Mediator

Marc Evan Jackson

Lyle

Ron Livingston

The Autograph Fan

Amy Schloerb

Jaden Jaworski

Jared Padalecki

Chip

Gil McKinney

Marney Bennett

Alaina Huffman

Osric

Osric Chau

The Hotel Clerk

Kathryne Dora Brown

Maury

Kurt Fuller

The Justin and Jaden Fan

Yeniffer Behrens

The Bearded Superfan

Laurie Fortier

Stella

Mandy Musgrave

Mary Helen

Jill Benjamin

Officer Murphy

Mitch Pileggi

Officer Billings

Vincent Ventresca

Guest Star

Michael Borja

Handler Beth

Carly Nykanen

Carly

Lindsay Sloane

Guest Star

Billy Moran

Kurt

Jayden Lund

Leslie Jo

Grace Bannon

Serge

Sebastian Roche

Rebecca

Kestrin Pantera

Officer Fernandez

Anthony L. Fernandez

Mel

Michael Cudlitz

Sue

Kim Rhodes

Guest Star

Stephen Norton

Officer Klint

Clint Culp

Doug Walderman

Misha Collins

The Paper Mache Fan

Meg Brogan

The Kent Fan

Celeste Pechous