Johnny Smith
Anthony Michael Hall
Sarah Bracknell Bannerman
Nicole de Boer
Rev. Gene Purdy
David Ogden Stiers
J.J. Bannerman
Connor Price
Sheriff Walt Bannerman
Chris Bruno
Bruce Lewis
John L. Adams
Herb Smith
Michael Cudlitz
Linda Finney
DeDee Pfeiffer
Guest Star
Ben Foster
Alex Sinclair
Jennifer Finnigan
J.J. Bannerman
Spencer Achtymichuk
Thaddeus Fallon - Age 12
Cole Heppell
Andrew Lyne
Patrick Bauchau
Greg Stillson
Sean Patrick Flanery
Marty Bracknell
Edward Asner
Dr. Alex Conners
Danny Masterson
Eva Cortez
Lourdes Benedicto
Santa/Nigel Hughes
Tim Henry
Rebecca Caldwell
Sarah Wynter
Roy Foldes
Derek Hamilton
Mrs. Stampwell
Gabrielle Rose
Mitch Stanton
Chris Kramer
Chloe Greeg/Laura Tierney
Jennifer Cortese
Hector the Foremanm
Frank Ferrucci
Gunman / Frank Monroe
Craig March
The Collector/Masked Man
Brian Markinson
Miranda Ellis
Laura Harris
Young Johnny
Kai Read-Friedmann
Deputy Roscoe
Bill Mondy
Ms. Anderson
Betty Linde
Alex at age 9
Jessica Amlee
Miguel
Wilmer Calderon
Nora Collins
Leanna Nash
Malcolm Janus
Martin Donovan
Callie Fallon
Ellen Dubin
Nathan Burke
Andrew Airlie
James Stillson
Gary Chalk
Enrique
Alonso Oyarzun
Doug Driscoll
Patrick Gilmore
Erica Carter
Joely Collins
Anna Turner
Cara Buono*
Dana Bright
Kristen Dalton
Dana Bright
Kendal Cross