Harry Vanderspeigle
Alan Tudyk
Asta Twelvetrees
Sara Tomko
Sheriff Mike Thompson
Corey Reynolds
D'Arcy Bloom
Alice Wetterlund
Ben Hawthorne
Levi Fiehler
Deputy Liv Baker
Elizabeth Bowen
Kate
Meredith Garretson
Max Hawthorne
Judah Prehn
Meredith Garretson
Dan Twelvetrees
Gary Farmer
David Logan
Alex Barima
Jay
Kaylayla Raine
Nurse Ellen
Diana Bang
Judy Cooper
Jenna Lamia*
Judy Cooper
Jenna Lamia
Baseball Player
Justin Rain
Sahar Karimi
Gracelyn Awad Rinke
General Eleanor McCallister
Linda Hamilton
Kayla
Sarah Podemski
Lisa Casper
Mandell Maughan
Joseph Rainier
Enver Gjokaj
Alien Harry Double / Cloaked Man
Keith Arbuthnot
Doctor Bishop
Lossen Chambers
Right Fielder
Coulton Jackson
Peter Bach / Peter Bach (voice)
Terry O'Quinn
Lewis
Alvin Sanders
Detective Lena Torres
Nicola Correia Damude
Abigail Hodges
Deborah Finkel
Orderly
Michael Roselli
Isabelle
Elvy
Jimmy
Ben Cotton
Patience 1st Base Coach
Kevin Bundy
42 (voice) / Octopus (voice)
Nathan Fillion
John
Trevor Carroll
Nurse
Gerardo Barcala
Carlyn
Alex Borstein
Dr. Ethan Stone
Michael Cassidy
Bobby Smallwood
Kesler Talbot
First Base Coach
Kevin Mundy
Lieutenant Hill
Rachel Colwell