Narrator (voice)

Bill Graves

Robert Schwartz

David Denowitz

Detective Vetter

Rhianna Radick

Daniel Ott

Mark Danger Mativier

Sean Taylor

Khairi Fortt

Raquel Calderin

Angela Perez

Chris O'Brien

Daren Donofrio

Clara Schwartz

Leah Barker

Jackie Garcia

Sharinna Allan

Maryann Ricker

Darcy Wright

Danielle DePalma

Lauren Quinn

Detective Thomas Lombardo

William Ryder

Jesus Maquiera

Mariano Mederos

Charles Wardlow

John Anantua

John Valverde / Carlitos Olivo

Alexander Pineiro

Kyle Hulbert

Trevor Jones

Randy Scheffield

Jeffrey Thompson

Dagoberto Vasquez

Melvin Vazquez

Detective Juanita Vetter

Lisa Hickman

Margaret O'Brien

Ashley Mitchell

Joel Schoenfeld

Peter O'Hara

Doretta Scheffield

Laura Frenzer

Diaz Brother

Ankur Rathee

Michael Paul Pfohl

Connor Dylan

Detective Arty Williams

Phil Grimaldi

Paul

Travis Branch

Detective Segovia

William Niola

Joyce Aparo

Lisa Tirone King

Detective Eddie Brown

Michael Lepre

Daniel C. Ott

Shelley Valfer

Jason Tibbs

Danny Blanda

Katherine Inglis

Juliette Kessler

Detective Sabel

Louis Anthony Colello

Police officer

Samuel Difiore

Karin Aparo

Michelle Young

Dennis Coleman

Nick Daly

Detective

Lou Piccoli

Corrections Officer #2

Joseph Bessette

Detective

Joel Shaw

Julia

Macy Cassera

Mrs. Markov

Pamela Ehn

Crime Scene Cop #2

Michael Cleary

Beat Cop

Sincée J. Daniels

Aliza Parsy

Hannah Cruz

Sima Parsy

Judith Anna Di Donato

Raviv Gabbay

Dan Sheynin

Detective Kenny

Pete Panuccio

Detective Joyce

Mark Weber

Blair

Susan Hedges

Mob Guy

Gaetano LoGiudice

Self - Author

Lara Bricker

Self - Author

Ann Rule

Self - Reporter

Larry Celona

Self - True Crime Author

Caitlin Rother

Self - True Crime Author

Stella Sands

Self - Author

Stephen Singular