Host
McKenzie Westmore
Judge
Ve Neill
Judge
Glenn Hetrick
Michael Westmore
Michael Westmore
Judge
Neville Page
Cat Paschen
Contestant
Faina Rudshteyn
Guest Star
Elizabeth Mitchell
Niko Gonzalez
Self - Contestant
Rachael Wagner
Contestant
Alan Tuskes
Tyler Green
Self - Contestant
Cig Neutron
Contestant
Philip Harrah
Cig Neutron
Self - Contestant
George Troester
Contestant
Suzanne Bostwick
George Troester III
Self - Contestant
Stella Sensel
Contestant
KC Mussman
Keaghlan Ashley
Self - Contestant
Keaghlan Ashley
Contestant
Laura McCormick
Contestant
Andrew Freeman
Self - Contestant / Contestant
Sasha Glasser
Stella Sensel
Contestant
Jill Burgner
Self - Contestant / Contestant
Damien Zimmerman
Adam Milicevic
Contestant
Kierstin LaPatka
Self - Contestant
Dina Cimarusti
Emily Serpico
Contestant
Nelson Cooper
Self - Contestant
Jason Hodges
Logan Long
Contestant
Joseph Drobezko
Self - Contestant
David O'Connell
Ben Ploughman
Contestant
Nicolas Fischer
Self - Contestant
Vince Niebla
Evan Hedges
Guest Star
Rick Baker
Guest
Cheyenne Jackson
Self - Contestant
Gwen Crew
Jasmine Ringo
Self - Contestant
Barry Mahoney
Melissa Ebbe
Self - Contestant
Scott Mitchell
Gage Hubbard
Self - Contestant
Gabby Leithsceal
Self - Contestant
Drew Talbot
Self - Contestant
Emily Serpico
Self - Contestant
Tyler Green
Self - Contestant
Evan Hedges
Self - Contestant
Melissa Ebbe
Self - Contestant
Catherine Paschen
Self - Contestant
Logan Long
Self - Contestant
Benjamin D. Ploughman
Self - Contestant
Adam Milicevic
Kiersten Lapatka
Self - Contestant
Gage Hubbard
Self - Contestant
Niko Gonzalez
Shiri (KC Mussman) Burdette
Self - Contestant
Jasmine Ringo
Contestant
Kayla "Jo" Holland
Contestant
Kelly Harris
Contestant
Yvonne Cox
Contestant
Graham Scofield
Contestant
Kevon Ward
Contestant
Jordan Patton
Matt Chris Wood
Contestant
Walter Welsh
Contestant
Matt Valentine
Contestant
Melanie Licata
Contestant
Derek Garcia