Host

McKenzie Westmore

Judge

Ve Neill

Judge

Glenn Hetrick

Michael Westmore

Michael Westmore

Judge

Neville Page

Cat Paschen

Contestant

Faina Rudshteyn

Guest Star

Elizabeth Mitchell

Niko Gonzalez

Self - Contestant

Rachael Wagner

Contestant

Alan Tuskes

Tyler Green

Self - Contestant

Cig Neutron

Contestant

Philip Harrah

Cig Neutron

Self - Contestant

George Troester

Contestant

Suzanne Bostwick

George Troester III

Self - Contestant

Stella Sensel

Contestant

KC Mussman

Keaghlan Ashley

Self - Contestant

Keaghlan Ashley

Contestant

Laura McCormick

Contestant

Andrew Freeman

Self - Contestant / Contestant

Sasha Glasser

Stella Sensel

Contestant

Jill Burgner

Self - Contestant / Contestant

Damien Zimmerman

Adam Milicevic

Contestant

Kierstin LaPatka

Self - Contestant

Dina Cimarusti

Emily Serpico

Contestant

Nelson Cooper

Self - Contestant

Jason Hodges

Logan Long

Contestant

Joseph Drobezko

Self - Contestant

David O'Connell

Ben Ploughman

Contestant

Nicolas Fischer

Self - Contestant

Vince Niebla

Evan Hedges

Guest Star

Rick Baker

Guest

Cheyenne Jackson

Self - Contestant

Gwen Crew

Jasmine Ringo

Self - Contestant

Barry Mahoney

Melissa Ebbe

Self - Contestant

Scott Mitchell

Gage Hubbard

Self - Contestant

Gabby Leithsceal

Self - Contestant

Drew Talbot

Self - Contestant

Emily Serpico

Self - Contestant

Tyler Green

Self - Contestant

Evan Hedges

Self - Contestant

Melissa Ebbe

Self - Contestant

Catherine Paschen

Self - Contestant

Logan Long

Self - Contestant

Benjamin D. Ploughman

Self - Contestant

Adam Milicevic

Kiersten Lapatka

Self - Contestant

Gage Hubbard

Self - Contestant

Niko Gonzalez

Shiri (KC Mussman) Burdette

Self - Contestant

Jasmine Ringo

Contestant

Kayla "Jo" Holland

Contestant

Kelly Harris

Contestant

Yvonne Cox

Contestant

Graham Scofield

Contestant

Kevon Ward

Contestant

Jordan Patton

Matt Chris Wood

Contestant

Walter Welsh

Contestant

Matt Valentine

Contestant

Melanie Licata

Contestant

Derek Garcia