Dan Ballard

John Payne

Rose Evans

Lizabeth Scott

Ned McCarthy

Dan Duryea

Dolly

Dolores Moran

Sheriff Wooley

Emile Meyer

Judge Cranston

Robert Warwick

Johnson

Harry Carey Jr.

Zachary Evans

Morris Ankrum

Michael 'Mitch' Evans

John Hudson

Johnson

Harry Carey

Kirk

Alan Hale Jr.

Wickers

Stuart Whitman

Paul Herbert, Telegrapher

Frank Sully

Rev. Field

Paul Birch

Reverend Field

Hugh Sanders

Mrs. Elmwood

Florence Auer

Dr. Elmwood

Roy Gordon

Taylor

Edgar Barrier

Prescott (uncredited)

Byron Foulger

Townsman

Al Hill

Cowboy (uncredited)

Myron Healey

Townsman

Gene Roth

Deputy

Al Haskell

Searcher

William Haade

Searcher

Frank Ellis

Searcher

I. Stanford Jolley

Townswoman

Barbara Woodell

Townswoman

Sheila Bromley

Man at Fire

Lane Chandler

Walt Little

Joe Devlin

Spectator

Burt Mustin

Blacksmith

John Dierkes

Joe

Ralph Sanford

Sheriff Wooley

Emile G. Meyer

Kirk

Alan Hale, Jr.*

Margo Woode