Jess Day

Zooey Deschanel

Nick

Jake Johnson

Coach

Damon Wayans Jr.

Schmidt

Max Greenfield

Cecilia 'Cece' Parikh

Hannah Simone

Winston

Lamorne Morris

Paul Genzlinger

Justin Long

Russell Schiller

Dermot Mulroney

Julia Cleary

Lizzy Caplan

Desiree

Raven Goodwin

Amanda

Lake Bell

Oliver

Ryan Kwanten

Caroline

Mary Elizabeth Ellis

Ouli

Jeanne Tripplehorn

Ice Cream Kid

Lukas Martin

Holly

Katrina Bowden

Gretchen

Natasha Lyonne

Remy

Jeff Kober

Dirk

Martin Starr

Joe Napoli

Phil Hendrie

Gina

Michaela Watkins

Beth

Eva Amurri

Tanya Lamontagne

Rachael Harris

Brooke

Katie Cassidy

Spencer

Ian Wolterstorff

Shelby

Kali Hawk

Werewolf Kid

Ada-Nicole Sanger

Hector

Lee Ki-hong

Lindsey

Sophie Kargman

Sherman

Ben Hoffman

Mexican Vendor

Aixa

Gary the Checker

Nate Shelkey

Neil

Thomas Lennon

Tambourine Girl

Kristen Best

Kim

Gillian Vigman

Gyno Guy

Craig Anstett

Man in Line

Christian Anderson

Cliff

Clark Duke

Brianna

Joey King

Sadie

June Diane Raphael

Aly Nelson

Nasim Pedrad

Young Schmidt

Aedin Mincks

Sarah Shiller

Annalise Basso

Hot Waitress

Danna Brady

Lena

Jessica Herman

Road Rage Guy

Steve Humphreys

Bianca

Tiffany Ariany

Gavin

Edin Gali

Nana

Madhur Jaffrey

Miriam

Jazz Raycole

Interviewer

Molly Bryant

Martin Fuller

Matt Besser

Chloe

Chloe Bridges

Will

Randall Park

Pawn Shop Owner

Paul Renteria

Kyle

Stephen Amell

Hospital Receptionist

Lyn Alicia Henderson

Greta

Roxana Ortega

Gino

Matthew Smith

Robby

Nelson Franklin

Delivery Guy

Potsch Boyd

Happy Man

Sean C. Graham

Benjamin

David Neher

Jimmy Longjam

Armaan Juneja

Frankenstein Kid

Troy Doherty

Krystal

Esther Povitsky

Nadia

Rebecca Reid

Toby

Marcus Scribner

Judge

Clyde Kusatsu

Photographer

Matt McVay

Unhappy Woman

Jeanette O'Connor

Mojan

Ajay Vidure

Reagan Lucas

Megan Fox

Plumber

Fitz Houston

Sweet Older Woman

Cindy Drummond

Peter

Jack Yang

Himself

Kareem Abdul-Jabbar

Bartender

Eric Winzenried

Douchebag 2

Erik Valdez

Skyler

Natalie Dreyfuss

Elvin

Blake Garrett

Masha

Sasha Neboga

Young Nick

Aaron Landon

Mrs. Schmidt

Barbara Kerford

Lingerie Store Clerk

Jennifer Wenger

Burt

Jack Carter

Haircut Guy

David Hoffman

Restaurant Manager

Drew Droege

Sam Sweeney

David Walton

Unhappy Man

Warren Sweeney

DJ Announcer

Darren Capozzi

Claire

Julie Brister

Claire

Rakefet Abergel

Woman Barfly

Nancy Lantis

Rochelle

Ashton Swinford

Valet Attendant

Fernando Rivera

Marhorie

Angela McEwan

Tia

Leslie Miller

Ben's Sidekick

E-Kan Soong

Young Jess

Portia Martine Berman