Jeffrey Dahmer

Evan Peters

Lionel Dahmer

Richard Jenkins

José Menendez

Javier Bardem

Joyce Dahmer

Penelope Ann Miller

Mary Louise 'Kitty' Menendez

Chloë Sevigny

Shari Dahmer

Molly Ringwald

Erik Menendez

Cooper Koch

Catherine Dahmer

Michael Learned

Ronald Flowers

Dyllon Burnside

Glenda Cleveland

Niecy Nash

Lyle Menendez

Nicholas Alexander Chavez

Dr. Jerome Oziel

Dallas Roberts

Tracy

Shaun J. Brown

Detective Murphy

Michael Beach

Patrick Kennedy

Colby French

Chazz

Colin Ford

Marta Cano

Marlene Forte

Detective Rauss

Matt Cordova

Leslie Abramson

Ari Graynor

Grandma Maria

Blanca Araceli

Judalon Smyth

Leslie Grossman

Richard Guerrero

Skyler Bible

Brian Andersen

Larry Clarke

Judge

Ivar Brogger

Dominick Dunne

Nathan Lane

Jeffrey's Lawyer

Ron Bush

Det. Les Zoeller

Jason Butler Harner

Nurse

Crystal Coney

Craig Cignarelli

Charlie Hall

Andy Cano

Nathen Gurrola

Miller

Labrandon Shead

Peter Hoffman

Jeff Perry

Jamie Pisarcik

Jade Pettyjohn

African American Man

Ken Ivy

Marzi Eisenberg

Mara Casey

Carlos Baralt

Enrique Murciano

Somsack Sinthasomphone

Brayden Maniago

Tim Rutten

Michael Gladis

Joyce

Kristin Lindquist

Southone Sinthasomphone

Khetphet Phagnasay

Jill Lansing

Jess Weixler

Boat Captain

Joseph Culp

Norton

Mark Kelly

Konerak Sinthasomphone

Kieran Tamondong

Judge Weisberg

Ross Mackenzie

Peter Cano

Miguel Pérez

Cousin Al

Luke Matthew Simon

Perry Berman

Tanner Stine

Chauffeur

Kamy D. Bruder

Coach

Max Hawksford

Umpire

Jack Perry

Big 5 Clerk

Sarah Summers

Wine Rep

Ashley Sutton

Det. Tom Linehan

Drew Powell

AMC Girl

Shelby Lee

Mark Heffernan

Andy Fitzgerald

Flor

Vanessa Lua

Dr. William Vicary

Gil Ozeri

Gerald Chaleff

Brad Culver

Sharon

Earlene Davis

Edwards

Jacob Figueroa

Glenn Stevens

Layne Herrin

Noelle

Chloe Oloren

Pam Bozanich

Milana Vayntrub

Juror #8

Melissa Bailey

Juror #4

Andrea Cañizares-Fernandez

Clerk

Helen Duffy

Juror #5

Peggy Dunne

Juror #10

Joyce King

Juror #1

Zabeth Russell

Brian Eslaminia

Ruben Vernier

Cowboy (Trick-or-Treater)

Ethan Bell

Yoda (Trick-or-Treater)

Jaja Corral

Half-Assed Zombie (Trick-or-Treater)

Grayson Thorne Kilpatrick

Gun Store Clerk

Lorraine Lerner

KTLA Reporter

Jake Reiner

Mrs. Hoffman

Tracey Silver

CBS 2 Reporter

Leanne Suter

Old Man

Jim Cody Williams*

Randolph Wright

Richard Holmes

Chief Marvin Iannone

Ron Bottitta

Officer Czarnocki

Walter Belenky

BHPD Officer

Christopher Christian

Motorcycle Cop

Justin Cuomo

Gang Member

Johnny D'Esposito

Locksmith

Anthony Elfonzia

Uniformed Officer

Brittany Freeth

Coroner

Gregory Gast

Sergeant West

Peter A. Hulne

Cop

Jason Jia

Dan Stanton

Don O. Knowlton

Zsa Zsa Gabor

Gisela Kovach

Oziel's Daughter

Isabella Rose Landau

Billy Wright

Ryan Maltz

Officer Mo Angel

Artie O'Daly

Weight Coach

Emory Ogletree II

Officer Butkus

Donovan Patton

Real Estate Agent

Jamie Tompkins

Philip

Alex Vaughan

Det. Edmonds

Gareth Williams

Klara Wright

Clara York

Robert Shapiro

Salvator Xuereb

Tony

Brandon Santana

Dr. Laurel Oziel

Tessa Auberjonois

Cop #2

Robert Sean Burke

Cop #1

Mario Cortez

Arnel Salvatierra

Rhied De Castro

Hayden Rodgers

Jake Elliott

Young Reporter

Stephen Friedrich

Adoption Agent

Roni Geva

Guy

Arthur Richardson

Realtor

Rebecca Safier

Donovan Goodreau

Anthony Turpel

Wealthy Socialite

Catherine Carlen

Handsome Actor

Joe Chambrello

Other Police Officer

Paul Chirico

Police Officer

Robert Dill

Movie Executive

Bradley Fisher

13 y / o Lyle

Dylan Friedman

Clerk

Kevin Gardner

Proctor

Nicole Ghastin

Gun Range Worker

Bernadette Guckin

Other Employee

Steve Hasley

Famous Actress

Lauren Lopez

Barbara

Valerie Perri

Employee

Jeremy W. Roberts

7 y / o Lyle

Jagger Rodriguez

5 y / o Erik

Stone Rooke

Diane Vandermolen

Juliet Rusche

Young José Menendez

Orlando Pineda

Young Kitty Menendez

Belle Shouse

Edgardo Diaz

Hugo Medina

Accountant

Guilford Adams

Lula Mae

Sally Brooks

Justice of the Peace

John Colton

Photographer

Matthew Gilmore

Contractor

John Gloria

Louise

Jennifer Ingrum

Hustler

Julian Larach

Dr. Anne Heller

Mandy Levin

Dr. Alan Fox

Rob Mainord

Woman

Brooke McCormick

Det. Mills

Jeff Pride

Dean of Students

Tom Simmons

Griffin Dunne

Dylan Barton

Alex Dunne

Will Block

George

John Churchill

Norma Novelli

Natalie Taylor Gray

Billy

David Lee Hess

Sweeney's Attorney

Matt Kaminsky

Linda

Amie MacKenzie

Ellen 'Lenny' Dunne

Shaw Purnell

Paul D'Emilio

Alex Rollins

Velma Smith

Amy Schloerb

Judge Burton Katz

Edward Singletary

John Thomas Sweeney

Neil Vincent Smith

Dominique Dunne

Megan Littler

Willie

O'Neil Cespedes

Carrie

Tanya Clarke

Doctor

Erin Coker

Nurse

Christine Corpuz

Inmate

Adam Dunnells

Joe

Vince Duvall

Other Inmate

Johnny James Fiore

Cousin Diane

Sarah Garofalo

OJ Simpson

Trae Ireland

Coach Wadlington

Jordan Matlock

David Conn

Paul Adelstein

Alternate Juror

Patrick Breen

Leigh

Vicki Lawrence

Court Clerk (Menendez Trial)

Cinda Adams

Reporter #2

Catherine Adell

Robbie

Tom Beyer

Driver (Erik's Van)

Stephen Bralver

Charles Gessler

Andy Forrest

Grant Walker

Jim Grollman

Scary Prisoner

Victor Gonzalez

Andrew

Joshua Hoover

Reporter #1

Desiree Mee Jung

Mary

Diane Yang

Carol Najera

Heather Knobel

Lesley

Anastasia Leddick

Anna Eriksson

Jamison McDermott

Newscaster

Yvonne Miranda

Guard (Anteroom)

Neiko Neal

Barry Levin

Andrew Oliveri

Phil

Reece Rios

Guard #3

Erik Rozet

Driver (Lyle's Van)

Stephen W. Schriver

Isaac

Sam Skolnik

Alfa Romeo Driver

Christian Telesmar

Fr. Viera

Juan Francisco Villa

Gina

Gina Vitori

Reporter #3

Jason Wayne Wong

Director

Jennifer Chambers Lynch