Maddie
Jessica Sula
Trish Collins
Kyla Pratt
Wes Stewart
Sebastian de Souza
Charlotte Graham
Sharon Leal
Cynthia McDermott
Alexis Carra
Vern Testaverde
Daniel Franzese
Craig Weiner
David Witts
Olivia O'Brien
Mischa Barton
Guest Star
Laura San Giacomo
Harper
Aubrey Peeples
Jane Stewart
Jenny O'Hara
Nyla
Meg DeLacy
Guest Star
Laura Bell Bundy
Laurel
Emma Fassler
Rebecca
Lindsay Pearce
Asa Stewart
Roberto Urbina
Margarita Jean-Baptiste
Paula Jai Parker
Ellie Dennis
Haley Lu Richardson
Zach
Keith Powers
Heather Granger
Anna Ross
Diesel
Nathan Sutton
Paul Morrell
Brad Beyer
Dr. Marcus Granger
Alex Carter
Donna Marie
Rebecca Metz
Doug McKewn
Jerod Meagher
James Graham
Tatum Shank
Brianna Discala-Leoni
Eileen Galindo
Alan
Leon
Counselor
Missy Doty
Benji
Lucas Adams
Stoner #1
Jordan Ray Fox
Student #1
Cassie Hernandez
Student #2
Sam Marra
Tobias
Luis Selgas
Eden
Aurelia Scheppers
AA Lady
Catherine Carlen
William Walker
Jon Lindstrom
Klaus
Sebastian Cole
Darnia
Paige Rowland
Carter
Joshua Sawtell
Driver
Christopher Goodman
Trish's Mother
Erika Alexander
Glover
Jordan Calloway
Mort
Max Gail
Grandpa Joe Ashby
Jack Betts
Gael
Brennan Keel Cook
Bernie
Mark Drexler
Orderly
David Haley
Priest
Hugh Holub
Constance von Sternberg
Reasha Honaker
Maureen
Laura Leigh Hughes
Mrs. Summers
Marianne Muellerleile
9-Year-Old Trish
Briana Roy
Sebastiano Conrad
Lawrence Stachowiak
Det. Covino
Alex Fernandez
Young Wes
TonyBoy Marin
Det. Guerrero
Kevin Rock
Young Asa
Kyle Villalovos
Jonah
Jordan James Smith*
Young Nyla
Genesis Ochoa
12-Year-Old Ellie
Chiara Aurelia
Coroners Office Worker Williams
Franco Barberis
Rene
Reid Collums
Officer Anderson
Josh Crotty
Young Maddie
Raquel Justice
Jasper Tollins
Clay Black
Minerva Higgins
Annie O'Donnell
Penelope Granger
Beth Rowe
7-Year-Old Maddie
Skylin Royal-Black
Counselor
Maggie Gwin
Young Cynthia Molina
Angeline Appel
Ethan
Ashton Moio
Policeman #1
Cantrell Harris
Mitch
Matt Raimo
Detective #1
Jeffrey Stubblefield
EMT
Samuel Whitten
Detective
David Grant Wright