Maddie Graham

Jessica Sula

Trish Collins

Kyla Pratt

Wes Stewart

Sebastian de Souza

Charlotte Graham

Sharon Leal

Cynthia McDermott

Alexis Carra

Vern Testaverde

Daniel Franzese

Craig Weiner

David Witts

Olivia O'Brien

Mischa Barton

Guest Star

Laura San Giacomo

Harper

Aubrey Peeples

Jane Stewart

Jenny O'Hara

Nyla

Meg DeLacy

Guest Star

Laura Bell Bundy

Laurel

Emma Fassler

Rebecca

Lindsay Pearce

Asa Stewart

Roberto Urbina

Margarita Jean-Baptiste

Paula Jai Parker

Ellie Dennis

Haley Lu Richardson

Zach

Keith Powers

Heather Granger

Anna Ross

Diesel

Nathan Sutton

Paul Morrell

Brad Beyer

Dr. Marcus Granger

Alex Carter

Donna Marie

Rebecca Metz

Doug McKewn

Jerod Meagher

James Graham

Tatum Shank

Brianna Discala-Leoni

Eileen Galindo

Alan

Leon

Counselor

Missy Doty

Benji

Lucas Adams

Stoner #1

Jordan Ray Fox

Student #1

Cassie Hernandez

Student #2

Sam Marra

Tobias

Luis Selgas

Eden

Aurelia Scheppers

AA Lady

Catherine Carlen

William Walker

Jon Lindstrom

Klaus

Sebastian Cole

Darnia

Paige Rowland

Carter

Joshua Sawtell

Driver

Christopher Goodman

Trish's Mother

Erika Alexander

Glover

Jordan Calloway

Mort

Max Gail

Grandpa Joe Ashby

Jack Betts

Gael

Brennan Keel Cook

Bernie

Mark Drexler

Orderly

David Haley

Priest

Hugh Holub

Constance von Sternberg

Reasha Honaker

Maureen

Laura Leigh Hughes

Mrs. Summers

Marianne Muellerleile

9-Year-Old Trish

Briana Roy

Sebastiano Conrad

Lawrence Stachowiak

Det. Covino

Alex Fernandez

Young Wes

TonyBoy Marin

Det. Guerrero

Kevin Rock

Young Asa

Kyle Villalovos

Jonah

Jordan James Smith*

Young Nyla

Genesis Ochoa

12-Year-Old Ellie

Chiara Aurelia

Coroners Office Worker Williams

Franco Barberis

Rene

Reid Collums

Officer Anderson

Josh Crotty

Young Maddie

Raquel Justice

Jasper Tollins

Clay Black

Minerva Higgins

Annie O'Donnell

Penelope Granger

Beth Rowe

7-Year-Old Maddie

Skylin Royal-Black

Counselor

Maggie Gwin

Young Cynthia Molina

Angeline Appel

Ethan

Ashton Moio

Policeman #1

Cantrell Harris

Mitch

Matt Raimo

Detective #1

Jeffrey Stubblefield

EMT

Samuel Whitten

Detective

David Grant Wright

Director

Jennifer Chambers Lynch

Director

Michael Schultz

Director

Lawrence Trilling

Director

Chris Grismer

Director

Andy Fickman

Director

David Paymer

Director

Larry Shaw

Director

Bethany Rooney

Director

Joanna Kerns