Jemaine

Jemaine Clement

Bret McKenzie

Bret McKenzie

Murray Hewitt

Rhys Darby

Mel

Kristen Schaal

Dave

Arj Barker

Doug

David Costabile

Eugene

Eugene Mirman

Bruce

James Callanan

Greg

Frank Wood

Hot Woman

Leigh Ann Larkin

Jim

Jim Gaffigan

Keitha's Housemate

Victoria Cesarski

Brahbrah

Kristen Wiig

Kid B

Michael Chen

The Edge U2's Guitarist

Liam Ferguson

Paula

Lucy Lawless

Dancing Bartender

Alan Gary

Sven

James Arden

Coco

Sutton Foster

Potential Client No. 2

Anjali Bhimani

Rapper

Joey Auzenne

Gel Girl

Madison McKinley

Himself

Art Garfunkel

NSA Agent

James Thomas Bligh

Bouncer

Randy Jones

Bartender

Mark A. Langston

Martin Clark

Greg Proops

Elton John Impersonator

Patton Oswalt

Nigel Saladu

Michael Potts

Stage Eugene

Anthony Fazio

Johnny Boy

Seymour Cassel

Keli

Dena Kaplan

Puppy Owner

Jennifer Montague

Australian Ambassador

Alan Dale

John

Lenny Venito

Police Officer West

Victor Williams

A.J. / Hotelier

Adrian Martinez

Art Garfunkel Fanatic

Mary Lynn Rajskub

Herself

Tiffany Limos

Record Executive

Ray Wineteer

Caitlin Goodman

Andrea Rosen

New Zealand Prime Minister Brian

Brian Sergent

Hansom Cab Driver

José Ramón Rosario

Stage Murray

Jonno Roberts

Waiter

Joe Dolinsky

Elton John Impersonator No. 2

Charles F. Rosenay

Keitha

Sarah Wynter

Sally

Rachel Blanchard

American Woman

Andrea Weston

Swim Team Member / Synchronized Swimmer

Aida Lembo

N.Z. Pedestrian

Elli

Police Officer

Kelly Taffe

Daryl Hall