Pam Hupp

Renée Zellweger

Leah Askey

Judy Greer

Joel Schwartz

Josh Duhamel

Russ Faria

Glenn Fleshler

Betsy Faria

Katy Mixon

Mariah Day

Gideon Adlon

Mark Hupp

Sean Bridgers

Janet

Suanne Spoke

Detective Ryan McCarrick

Mac Brandt

Captain Mike Lang

Adam David Thompson

Lily Day

Olivia Luccardi

Travis Hupp

Drew Scheid

Narrator (voice)

Keith Morrison

Officer Divozzo

Michael Carollo

Louis Gumpenberger

Jeff Ryan Baker

Nate Swanson

Ben Chase

Jerry

Barry Clifton

Detective Brian Hilke

Cuyle Carvin

Bobbie

Catherine Carlen

Young Pam Hupp

Emily Topper

Bob Rivers

Kenny Alfonso

Officer Carrigan

Jeremy Dean

Judge Mennemeyer

Heather Magee

Tina

Rachael Thompson

Tammy

Ann Mahoney

Minnie

Patricia French

Scott

Billy Slaughter

Randy Gunderson

Kyler Porche

Sean Walker

Dickson Obahor

Detective Merkel

Jesse Scott Egan

Jim

William McGovern

Cousin Mary

Lara Grice

Greg Chatton

Michael Krikorian

Evan

Morgan Roberts

Polygrapher

Randall D. Cunningham

Bradford Kessler

Jay Pennington

Teenage Witch

Didi Costine

Juror #2

Jeff Robins

Sarah Hupp

Sarah Stipe

Young Mark Hupp

Alec Zais

O'Fallon County Operator

Jessie Terrebonne

Gus

Ricky Catter

Lisa

Lena Clark

Luci

Susan Shalhoub Larkin

CSI Tech

Victoria Harris

Firefighter

Anthony Michael Frederick

Cathy Singer

Alice Barrett

Whitney

Cindy Pol

Channel 2 Reporter

Michael Hinson

Plastic Surgeon

Gralen Bryant Banks

911 Operator

Terese Aiello

Greg Chatton

Michael Krikorkian

Leah Askey's Daughter

Merah Benoit

Sarah at 11 Years Old / Young Sarah

Clayton Eustis

Michael J. Kruse

Rob Steinberg

Bailiff

John C. Klein

Young Mark Hupp

Alec James Zais

Shirley Neumann

Celia Weston

Friendly Nurse

Samantha Beaulieu

News Reporter

Tracy Brotherton

Officer Rose

Jordan Mann

O'Fallon Office Dave

Mike Harkins

Darla

Jasmine Martin

Bailiff

Tom Cain

Courtroom Bailiff

Chad Governale

Juror #3

David Kors

Russ' Family Member

Ron Centanni

Sarah at 6 Years Old

Harper Herrin

Zumba Instructor

Lorna Street Dopson

Big Shot Manager

Jackson Kelly

Reporter #1

Liz Reinhardt Delsa

Inmate

Wendy Conrad

Judge Ted House

Bill Martin Williams

Prisoner

Suzette Lange

Judge Cunningham

Kurt McKinney

911 Operator

Terese Aiello

CSI Tech

Jordan V. Allen

Judge Ohmer

Douglas M. Griffin

Bubbly Acolyte

Madeline Colombo

Auctioneer #1

René J.F. Piazza

Cybercrimes Expert

Ian Hoch

Teen Pet Shop Employee

Nicole Francis Miller

Realtor Sally

Rachel G. Whittle

Carol Alford

Kerry Cahill

Louis' Mom

Becki Davis

PV Fake Louis

Luke Sexton

Director

Logan Kibens

Director

Adam Kane

Director

Scott Winant