Pam Hupp
Renée Zellweger
Leah Askey
Judy Greer
Joel Schwartz
Josh Duhamel
Russ Faria
Glenn Fleshler
Betsy Faria
Katy Mixon
Mariah Day
Gideon Adlon
Mark Hupp
Sean Bridgers
Janet
Suanne Spoke
Detective Ryan McCarrick
Mac Brandt
Captain Mike Lang
Adam David Thompson
Lily Day
Olivia Luccardi
Travis Hupp
Drew Scheid
Narrator (voice)
Keith Morrison
Officer Divozzo
Michael Carollo
Louis Gumpenberger
Jeff Ryan Baker
Nate Swanson
Ben Chase
Jerry
Barry Clifton
Detective Brian Hilke
Cuyle Carvin
Bobbie
Catherine Carlen
Young Pam Hupp
Emily Topper
Bob Rivers
Kenny Alfonso
Officer Carrigan
Jeremy Dean
Judge Mennemeyer
Heather Magee
Tina
Rachael Thompson
Tammy
Ann Mahoney
Minnie
Patricia French
Scott
Billy Slaughter
Randy Gunderson
Kyler Porche
Sean Walker
Dickson Obahor
Detective Merkel
Jesse Scott Egan
Jim
William McGovern
Cousin Mary
Lara Grice
Greg Chatton
Michael Krikorian
Evan
Morgan Roberts
Polygrapher
Randall D. Cunningham
Bradford Kessler
Jay Pennington
Teenage Witch
Didi Costine
Juror #2
Jeff Robins
Sarah Hupp
Sarah Stipe
Young Mark Hupp
Alec Zais
O'Fallon County Operator
Jessie Terrebonne
Gus
Ricky Catter
Lisa
Lena Clark
Luci
Susan Shalhoub Larkin
CSI Tech
Victoria Harris
Firefighter
Anthony Michael Frederick
Cathy Singer
Alice Barrett
Whitney
Cindy Pol
Channel 2 Reporter
Michael Hinson
Plastic Surgeon
Gralen Bryant Banks
911 Operator
Terese Aiello
Greg Chatton
Michael Krikorkian
Leah Askey's Daughter
Merah Benoit
Sarah at 11 Years Old / Young Sarah
Clayton Eustis
Michael J. Kruse
Rob Steinberg
Bailiff
John C. Klein
Young Mark Hupp
Alec James Zais
Shirley Neumann
Celia Weston
Friendly Nurse
Samantha Beaulieu
News Reporter
Tracy Brotherton
Officer Rose
Jordan Mann
O'Fallon Office Dave
Mike Harkins
Darla
Jasmine Martin
Bailiff
Tom Cain
Courtroom Bailiff
Chad Governale
Juror #3
David Kors
Russ' Family Member
Ron Centanni
Sarah at 6 Years Old
Harper Herrin
Zumba Instructor
Lorna Street Dopson
Big Shot Manager
Jackson Kelly
Reporter #1
Liz Reinhardt Delsa
Inmate
Wendy Conrad
Judge Ted House
Bill Martin Williams
Prisoner
Suzette Lange
Judge Cunningham
Kurt McKinney
911 Operator
Terese Aiello
CSI Tech
Jordan V. Allen
Judge Ohmer
Douglas M. Griffin
Bubbly Acolyte
Madeline Colombo
Auctioneer #1
René J.F. Piazza
Cybercrimes Expert
Ian Hoch
Teen Pet Shop Employee
Nicole Francis Miller
Realtor Sally
Rachel G. Whittle
Carol Alford
Kerry Cahill
Louis' Mom
Becki Davis
PV Fake Louis
Luke Sexton