Vance (Marshal Vance Cordell)
Randolph Scott
Sundance Kid
Robert Ryan
Cheyenne
Anne Jeffreys
John J. Pettit
George 'Gabby' Hayes
John J. Pettit - Bank President
George "Gabby" Hayes
Madge Allen (Pettit's Daughter/Cordell's Fiancée)
Jacqueline White
Cole Younger
Steve Brodie
Jim Younger
Tom Keene
Jim Younger
Richard Powers
John Younger
Robert Bray
Emmett Dalton
Lex Barker
Bob Dalton
Walter Reed
Grat Dalton
Michael Harvey
Billy the Kid
Dean White
Wild Bill Doolin
Robert Armstrong
Wild Bill Yeager
Tom Tyler
Arkansas Kid
Lew Harvey
Johnny Allen
Gary Gray
Muley Wilson
Walter Baldwin
Emily
Minna Gombell
George Mason (Outlaw)
Warren Jackson
Judge Harper
Jason Robards
Wade Templeton (uncredited)
Harry Shannon
Dave
Robert Clarke
Leslie - Station Agent/Telegrapher
Ernie Adams
Townsman
Victor Adamson
Elmer
Charles McAvoy
Scout
Larry McGrath
Mrs. Webster
Polly Bailey
Conductor
Brandon Beach
Deputy
Billy Vincent
Deputy
Howard McCrorey
Deputy
Hank Bell
Guthrie Townsman
Eddie Borden
Donald Webster
George Nokes
Tim Webster
Ronnie Ralph
Deputy
Chet Brandenburg
Outlaw
Bob Burrows
Farmer
Forrest Taylor
Ed the Posse Leader
Lane Chandler
Steve the Stagecoach Driver
Bud Osborne
Grey Eagle
Charles Stevens
Col Markham
Kenneth MacDonald
Mrs. Moore
Ida Moore
Outlaw
Dan Foster
Soldier
Richard Thorne
Doc Peters
John Hamilton
Bank Clerk
Cyril Ring
Auctioneer
Earle Hodgins
Muley Wilson
Walter S. Baldwin
Grat Dalton
Michael Martin Harvey
Auctioneer
Earl Hodgins