Vance (Marshal Vance Cordell)

Randolph Scott

Sundance Kid

Robert Ryan

Jeannie 'Cheyenne' McBride

Anne Jeffreys

John J. Pettit - Bank President

George "Gabby" Hayes

Madge Allen (Pettit's Daughter/Cordell's Fiancée)

Jacqueline White

Cole Younger

Steve Brodie

Jim Younger

Tom Keene

Jim Younger

Richard Powers

John Younger

Robert Bray

Emmett Dalton

Lex Barker

Bob Dalton

Walter Reed

Grat Dalton

Michael Harvey

Billy the Kid

Dean White

Wild Bill Doolin

Robert Armstrong

Wild Bill Yeager

Tom Tyler

Arkansas Kid

Lew Harvey

Johnny Allen

Gary Gray

Muley Wilson

Walter Baldwin

Emily

Minna Gombell

George Mason

Warren Jackson

Judge Harper

Jason Robards

Wade Templeton (uncredited)

Harry Shannon

Dave

Robert Clarke

Grey Eagle

Charles Stevens

Leslie - Station Agent/Telegrapher

Ernie Adams

Townsman

Victor Adamson

Elmer

Charles McAvoy

Scout

Larry McGrath

Mrs. Webster

Polly Bailey

Conductor

Brandon Beach

Deputy

Billy Vincent

Deputy

Howard McCrorey

Deputy

Hank Bell

Guthrie Townsman

Eddie Borden

Donald Webster

George Nokes

Tim Webster

Ronnie Ralph

Deputy

Chet Brandenburg

Outlaw

Bob Burrows

Farmer

Forrest Taylor

Ed the Posse Leader

Lane Chandler

Steve the Stagecoach Driver

Bud Osborne

Col Markham

Kenneth MacDonald

Mrs. Moore

Ida Moore

Outlaw

Dan Foster

Soldier

Richard Thorne

Doc Peters

John Hamilton

Bank Clerk

Cyril Ring

Auctioneer

Earle Hodgins

Muley Wilson

Walter S. Baldwin

Grat Dalton

Michael Martin Harvey

Auctioneer

Earl Hodgins