Jeff/Mr. Pickles

Jim Carrey

Sebestian

Frank Langella

Deirdre

Catherine Keener

Jill

Judy Greer

Scott Perera

Bernard White

Peter

Justin Kirk

Will Pickles

Cole Allen

Maddy

Juliet Morris

Giggles

Juliocesar Chavez

Clay / Snagglehorse

Rich Fulcher

Cassidy

Julitta Scheel

Tara Lipinski

Tara Lipinski

Nurse

Juliette Jeffers

Snagglehorse Tail / Puppeteer

Lexi Pearl

Joanne

Kelly Coffield Park

Snagglehorse Head / Puppeteer

David Crespin

Bert

Barry Rothbart

B.D.

Coda Boesel

Soap Scum / Puppeteer

Dorien Davies

Secret Chef / Puppeteer

Mike Quinn

James

Luca Bleu Darnell

Assistant

Ashleigh Morghan

Stephanie Burns

Nicole Marie Appleby

Brad Marchand

Frank Bond

Hopscotch The Sasquatch

Dick Van Dyke

Brian

Jaeden Bettencourt

Beth

Elizabeth Tripp

Rabbi Epstein

Joel Swetow

Marsha

Karen Huie

Ennui Le Triste

Dan Garza

Astronotter

Gwen Hollander

News Anchor

Kerry Hoyt