Self

Stan Lee

Self

Michelle Rodriguez

Self

Lynda Carter

Jonathan Nolan

Rob Lowe

William Marston

Chris Patrick-Simpson

Self

Todd McFarlane

Self

Denys Cowan

Madison Cipparone

Derek T. Dingle

Rob Liefeld

Self

Kevin Smith

David Goyer

Jerry Siegel

Brendan Taylor

Elizabeth Holloway

Morgana Wyllie

Self

Jim Lee

Michael Davis

Self

Famke Janssen

Joe Shuster

Blaine Anderson

Self

Charles Brownstein

Guest

Wayne Brady

Guest

Steve Ditko

Robert Kirkman

Self

J.K. Simmons

Jack Liebowitz

Byron Noble

Max Gaines

Jason Stevens

Self

Eddie DeAngelini

Guest

Method Man

Guest

Lauren Shuler Donner

Guest

Patty Jenkins

Guest

Van Jones

Guest

Erik Larsen

Self

Steve Englehart

Guest

Christopher Priest

Guest

Jim Valentino

Guest

Neal Adams

Guest

Jim Shooter

Guest

Christos Gage

Self

Mark Evanier

Guest

Marc Silvestri

Guest

Lucy Lawless

Guest

Richard Donner

Guest

Reginald Hudlin

Self

Danny Fingeroth

Guest

Paul Levitz

Guest

Whilce Portacio

Guest

Wally Pfister

Self

Sean Howe

Self

Bill Sienkiewicz

Self

Roy Thomas

Self

Jessica Tseang

Narrator

Keri Russell

Self

Gal Gadot

Self

Tim Hanley

Self

Phil Jimenez

Self

Travis Langley

S&M Man

Roberto Lanzas

Self

Mike Madrid

Self

Andy Mangels

Senior

Paige McCulloch

S&M Woman

Destiny Millns

Self

Barbara Moss

Self

Trina Robbins

Self

Jennifer K. Stuller

Neal Adams

Tom Belding

Bully

Peter Bundic

Young Jerry Siegel

Beni Gottesman

Young Joe Shuster

Bito Gottesman

1940s Judge #1

Robert Leaf

Joanne Siegel

Emma Middleton

Harry Donefeld

John Perrotta

1960s Judge #2

Ken Speckeen

Self

Nicky Wheeler-Nicholson

Self

Jeffrey Moulton

Self

Mark D. White

Self

Derek Dingle

Self

Arvell Jones

Self

Keith Pollard

Self

Matt Wayne

Erik Larsen

Dan Davidson

Robert Kirkman

Greg Herburger