Detective Marc Bass

Travis Dunn

Daughter

Jaden Lily Branson

Melissa's 6 year old daughter

Addianne Graham

Narrator

Joe Alaskey

Brian Lee

Tony Toste

Teacher

Marcy Conway

Receptionist

Ivy Rhodes

Investigator Lee

Chris Caulpetzer

Jimmy Steed

John Hedgecoth

Melissa White

Leigh Scarbrough

Grant Hendrickson

Jackson Dale

Keith Lintz

Hunter Wayne Brown

Kevin's Dad

Paul Jones

Edward Picard

Frank Brennan

Zimmerman, Shane

Levi Krevinghaus

Toney Kelough

Jeff Kidd

Secretary

Jeni Lamm

Jeff Roesler

Michael Scott Thomas

Linda

Katie Henegar Smith

Peter Jodoin

Christopher James

Ryan Waters

Peter Aylward

Carla Fuqua

Brittney Saylor

Chris Cartagena

Rose Opengart

Michael Taylor

Jeff Weekley

Det. Joey Stone

Josh Smith

Landlord

David Lee Poe Jr.

John Borton

Nicholas Mariano

David Weist

Joshua Maddox

Jeffrey Williams

David Watts

John Borton

Nick Mariano

Chief Blackmon / Polygraph Examiner

Peter Buitenhek

Agent Randy Upton

Jamie Renell

Chief Richard Hunt

William J Mode

Julie day

Laura Fraker

Detective Kevin Herald

Levi Burdick

Jason Steed

Vinnie Vineyard

Belinda

Laura Schoonmaker

Det. Kristin Daly

Lynn Talley

Det. Robert Freitas

Jonathan K. Riggs

Self - Narrator

Anthony D. Call

Det. Fabian Suarez

Mike Howard

Michelle Cartagena

Anna Grace Stewart

Jim Bettis

Teague Quillen

Cheri Kiplinger

Julie Haught

Neighbor

Allen Koch

Funeral attendee

Gage Lawson

Kyle Wolfe

Wil Deusner

Lance Jones

Kenny Davis