Host

Alyson Hannigan

Self - Judge

Penn Jillette

Self - Judge

Teller

Guest Star

Jason Suran

Guest Star

Alex Boyer

Guest Star

Paige Thompson

Guest

Billy Davis Jr.

Guest Star

Bentley Burns

Guest

Scott Wolf

Guest Star

Carrot Top

Guest

Marilyn McCoo

Self - Presenter

Jonathan Ross

Guest Star

Andi Gladwin

Guest Star

Jonathan Lachance

Guest Star

Andy Deemer

Guest Star

Rokas Bernatonis

Guest Star

David Corsaro

Self - Host

Brooke Burke

Guest Star

Stanley Zhou

Guest Star

Zak Mirz

Guest Star

Roddy McGie

Guest Star

John Fitzsimmons

Guest Star

Heather McDonald

Guest Star

Thomas Solomon

Guest Star

Lindsey Noel

Self - Magician / Self

Jandro López

Self

Jesse Eisenberg

Self

Kyle Eschen

Self

Dan Harlan

Self

Brett Loudermilk

Self

Ryan Joyce

Himself

Louie Anderson

Himself

Murray Hatfield

Herself

Teresa Hatfield

Herself

Misty Lee

Himself

Shin Lim

Self

Richard Turner

Self - Magician

Blaise Serra

Himself

Terry Fator