Buffy Summers
Sarah Michelle Gellar
Alexander "Xander" Harris
Nicholas Brendon
Willow Rosenberg
Alyson Hannigan
Cordelia Chase
Charisma Carpenter
Rupert Giles
Anthony Stewart Head
Marc
Burke Roberts
The Master
Mark Metcalf
Spike
James Marsters
Dave
Chad Lindberg
Marcie Ross
Clea Duvall
Anya
Emma Caulfield
Kyle DuFours
Eion Bailey
Amy Madison
Elizabeth Anne Allen
Oz
Seth Green
Angel
David Boreanaz
Luke / The Judge
Brian Thompson
Billy Palmer
Jeremy Foley
Owen Thurman
Christopher Wiehl
Rhonda Kelley
Michael McCraine
Fritz
Jamison Ryan
Catherine Madison
Robin Riker
Principal Snyder
Armin Shimerman
Dawn Summers
Michelle Trachtenberg
Natalie French
Musetta Vander
Thelonius
Pierrino Mascarino
Collin
Andrew Ferchland
Riley Finn
Marc Blucas
Jenny Calendar
Robia LaMorte
Principal Bob Flutie
Ken Lerner
Tor Hauer
Brian Gross
Mitch
Ryan Bittle
Senior Cheerleader
Amanda Wilmshurst
Morgan Shay
Richard Werner
Blayne Moll
Jackson Price
Lishanne
Nicole Prescott
Joyce Summers
Kristine Sutherland
Heidi Barrie
Jennifer Sky
Real Natalie French
Jean Speegle Howard
Ms. Miller
Denise Dowse
Hank Summers
Dean Butler
School Nurse
Edith Fields
Van Driver
Robert Mont
Mrs. Jackson
Lenora May
Bud 1
John Knight
Meanest Vamp
Charles Wesley
Darla
Julie Benz
Male Student
Damon Sharpe
Andrew Borba
Geoff Meed
Wendell
Justin Urich
Mr. Pole
Jim Doughan
Elliot
Chasen Hampton
Lance
Jeff Maynard
Dr. Gregory
William Monaghan
Kevin
Scott Gurney
Thomas
J. Patrick Lawlor
Harmony Kendall
Mercedes McNab
Moloch / Malcolm (voice)
Mark Deakins
Homeless Guy
Jack Knight
Laura
J. Robin Miller
Lisa
Natasha Pearce
Dr. Weirick
James Stephens
Thomas
J. Patrick Lawlor
Mysterious Guy
Paul Felix Montez
Jesse
Eric Balfour
Ms. Tishler
Terry Walters
Agent Doyle
Mark Phelan
Mr. Anderson
David Brisbin
Sid (voice)
Tom Wyner
Teacher
Natalie Strauss
Jonathan Levinson
Danny Strong
Boy
Carmine Giovinazzo
Andrew Wells / Cyrus
Tom Lenk
Girl #1
Amy Chance
Faith
Eliza Dushku
Girl #2
Tupelo Jereme
Aura
Persia White
Warren Mears
Adam Busch
Band Member
Tony Delocht
Band Member
Ernie Longoria
Band Member
William Riley
Mayor Richard Wilkins
Harry Groener
Band Member
Mike Summers
Ben
Charlie Weber
Band Member
Steve Summers
Principal Robin Wood
D.B. Woodside
Kennedy
Iyari Limon
Glory
Clare Kramer
Graham Miller
Bailey Chase
Forrest Gates
Leonard Roberts
Amanda
Sarah Hagan
Maggie Walsh
Lindsay Crouse
Adam
George Hertzberg
Rona
Indigo
Devon MacLeish
Jason Hall
Clem / Loose Skinned Demon
James C. Leary
Vi
Felicia Day
Halfrek / Cecily Addams
Kali Rocha
Larry Blaisdell
Larry Bagby
Ubervamp / Gentleman / Gnarl
Camden Toy
Jinx
Troy Blendell
Murk
Todd Duffey
Percy West
Ethan Erickson
Molly
Clara Bryant
Willy the Snitch
Saverio Guerra
Caleb
Nathan Fillion
Mr. Trick
K. Todd Freeman
Parker Abrams
Adam Kaufman