Jamie

Joey King

Shira

Andrea Savage

Ned Winkle

Paul Scheer

Luke Shay

Jack Kilmer

Dotty

June Squibb

Hope

Erin Darke

Emily

Kelly Lamor Wilson

March

Stephen Ruffin

Dylan

Logan Medina

Buck

Travis James

Officer Quincy

Elise DuQuette

Herman Lorenz

Rick Andosca

Father Patrick

Bill Eudaly

Randall Smithton

Paul Ryden

Todd Brown / Park Ranger

Nick Caruso

Nico /Football Bro

Jared Gray

Doctor Spaulding

John Weselcouch

Nurse 1

Melissa Youngblood

Mean Girl

Morganne Roark

Brunette Girl

Danyelle Foord

Old Woman

Leslie Hunt

Station Police officer

Jerry Mortel

Nurse 2

Tina Nixon

Teen Shira

Danielle Francese

Josh, Emily's old crush

Fin Argus

Baby Jamie

Olivia Morgenstern

Jamie's Friend

Monica Mathis