Gary

Calvin Reeder

Brad (segment "Tape 56")

Adam Wingard

Brad

Lane Hughes

Rox (segment "Tape 56")

Kentucker Audley

Lily

Hannah Fierman

Old Man

Frank Stack

Steve (segment "Tape 56")

Simon Barrett

Shane

Mike Donlan

Sam

Joe Swanberg

Stephanie

Sophia Takal

Fifth Thug (segment "Tape 56")

Andrew Droz Palermo

Patrick

Joe Sykes

The Stalker

Kate Lyn Sheil

Emily

Helen Rogers

James

Daniel Kaufman

Spider

Jason Yachanin

Clint

Drew Sawyer

Abbey

Sarah Byrne

Tabitha

Melissa Boatright

Lisa

Jas Sams

Joey Brenner

Drew Moerlein

Lisa (segment "Amateur Night")

Jasper Lewis

Bartender (segment "Amateur Night")

Nicholas Tecosky

Patrick

Joey Sykes*

Lisa's Friend (segment "Amateur Night")

Lisa Marie Thomas

Bouncer (segment "Amateur Night")

Rob Mosca

Chad

Chad Villella

Matt (segment "10/31/98")

Matt Bettinelli-Olpin

Tyler (segment "10/31/98")

Tyler Gillett

Paul (segment "10/31/98")

Paul Natonek

Local DJ

Graham Reznick

Wendy (segment "Tuesday the 17th")

Norma C. Quinones

The Girl (segment "10/31/98")

Nicole Erb

Cult Leader (segment "10/31/98")

John Walcutt

Cult Dude (segment "10/31/98")

Bilal Mir

Samantha

Jeannine Yoder

Cult Dude (segment "10/31/98")

Damion Stephens

The Glitch

Bryce Burke

Cult Dude (segment "10/31/98")

Koz McRae

Victim By Wall

Jennifer Sacks

Eric (segment "10/31/98")

Eric Curtis

Niky (segment "10/31/98")

Nicole Boccumini

Victim in River (segment "Tuesday the 17th")

Glenn McQuaid

Melinda (segment "10/31/98")

Melinda Fleming

The New Girl (segment "The Sick Thing That Happened To Emily When She Was Younger")

Liz Harvey

Boy Alien

Isaiah Hillman

Girl Alien

Corrie Lynne Fitzpatrick

Little Girl Alien

Taliyah Hillman

Cult Dude

Koz McCrane

Passerby

Joshua Carey

Passerby

Justin Martinez

Andrew Palermo