Sal
Nick Offerman
Max
Keith Poulson
Lyla
Jess Weixler
Clarissa
Stephanie Hunt
Memorial Man
Kevin Corrigan
Lyla's Father
Marshall Bell
Adult Lyle
Jonathan Togo
Therapist
Megan Mullally
Ex-Wife
Kate Lyn Sheil
Girl at the Birthday Party (as Tabyana Ford)
Tabyana Ali
Paula
Anna Margaret Hollyman
Steakhouse Patron/Homeless Man
Ted Beck*
Wedding Singer
Bob Schneider
Businessman
Chris Doubek
Car Rental Employee
Mike Wachs
Wedding Guest #1
Josh Ashy Holden
Wedding Guest #2
Nick Ashy Holden
You Guys Lady
Margie Beegle
You Guys Lady's Son
Josh Meyer
First Customer
Alex Ross Perry
Derek
Stephen Gurewitz
Ambulance Screen Doctor
Andrew Bujalski
Caterer #1
Bill Wise
Caterer #2
Jonny Mars
Bus Boy #1
Ali Rose Garcia
Bus Boy #2
Julio Lucero
16-year-old Wedding Guest
Brigid Flanagan
Bellman
Nicky Kazar
Chapstick Man
G-Su Paek
Chapstick Woman
Sun Jue Shin
Television Announcer
Adam Scott
Lyle Age 5
Gabriel Keller
Lyle Age 10
Ian Graffunder
Lyle Age 15
Jake Lewis
Preacher #1
Mark Miller
Preacher #2
Paul Steckler
Ex-Wife Bedmate
Sean Price Williams
Boring Guy
Jason Harter
Old Woman Driver
Joye Flanagan
Girl Thrown in Pool
Ella Graffunder
Paramedic
Jeffry Templet
Maid
Yvonne Rodriguez
Wedding Band Member
Taylor Muse
Wedding Band Member
Tommy Blank
Wedding Band Member
Matt Parmenter
Wedding Band Member
Jeff Weathers
Divorce Lawyer
Chrissy Flat
Lyle's Infant Son
Locke Reyna
Lyle's Infant Son
Madden Reyna
Lyle's Son Age 10
William Sotelo