Eileen O'Neal

Martha Plimpton

Pat

Jay R. Ferguson

Jimmy O"Neal

Matthew Shively

Kenny

Noah Galvin

Shannon

Bebe Wood

Jodi

Mary Hollis Inboden

Grandma Agnes

Frances Conroy

Michael-Gregory

Ian Gomez

Himself

Jimmy Kimmel

Father Phil

Brian Huskey

Mimi

Hannah Marks

Himself

Tim Gunn

VP Murray

Matt Oberg

Ricky

Garrett Clayton

Sandra

Emily Rutherfurd

Sam

Jamie Denbo

Scott

Charles Emmett

Gloria

Jessica Snow-Wilson

Ms. Hanson

Abby Miller

Jesus

Jeremy Lawson

Guy 2

Brett Pierce

Archie

Phil LaMarr

Lacey

Kaylee Bryant

Cheryl

Chloe Wepper

Zack

Pat Finn

Gay Otter

Jeff Bowser

Minister

Mary Kathleen Gordon

Officer Golaski

Michelle C. Bonilla

Drew

Noah Crawford

Suzie

Anita Barone

Ms. Walker

Allison Bills

Stuart

Caleb Pierce

Nancy

Melanie Paxson

Gay Bear

John F. Schaffer

Vladimir

Jim Blanchette

Waitress

Molly Morgan

Marcia Worthman

Sarayu Blue

Devon

Chris V. Pipkin

Annoyed Waitress

Tracy Meyer

Fran

Kate Fuglei

Apartment Manager

Rodney J. Hobbs

Doug

Preston Strother

Bartender

Mike Nojun Park

Jonathan

Jacob Melton

Madison

Madison Iseman

Cologne Man

Max Emerson

Goon

Rickey Eugene Brown

Waiter

Marvin Ryan

St. Barkley Student

Kellen Pembleton

Nerdy Boy

Ethan Lee

Dr. Filbert

Michael D. Cohen

Kenny Lee

Sergio Martínez

Bishop Perez

Efrain Figueroa

Pretty Woman

Kalpana Pot

Man

Anthony Soike

Judge

Nancy Linehan Charles

Ethan

Christopher Avila

Jake

Conrad K Pratt

Old Woman

Elayn J. Taylor

Doug

Jeremy Batiste

Maleficent

Caroline Morahan

Senio Boy

Damien Diaz

Waitress

Jinhee Joung

Girl 1

Tabitha Brownstone*

Woman

Gloria Calderon Kellett

Woman

Toni Torres

Paula

Ann Maddox

Girl 2

Sasha Compère

Gangbanger

Scott Menville

Saleswoman

Irene White

Sebastian

Jake McLean

Crystal

Keri Safran

Middle Aged Dentist

Scot Zeller

Waitress

Jinhee Joung

Woman

Gloria Calderon Kellett

Director

Phil Traill

Director

Elliot Hegarty

Director

Silver Tree

Director

Todd Holland