Heather

Rachel Brosnahan

David

Travis Fimmel

Brandon Boyd

Asa Butterfield

Bitsy

Christina Ricci

Andy

John Marshall Jones

Kyle

Colin Ford

Susan

Ming-Na Wen

Sheriff Stallings

Karen Allen

Logan

Victoria Justice

Simon

Jacob Batalon

Ashley Whitmore, III

Alex Fitzalan

Amelia / Amelia (voice)

Thailey Roberge

Sebastian Klepner

James Ransone

Megan

Emily Hampshire

Dale

Donavon Stinson

Maria Vazquez

Danay Garcia

Lindstrom

Joshua Mikel

Scott Wilke

Greyston Holt

Pigtails

Brea St. James

Bobby Wu

Dan Ginnane

The Prisoner

Lisa Chandler

Hannah

Taissa Farmiga

Blake

Ron Livingston

David Freeman

Drew Ray Tanner

Kyle Wilson

Nick Purcha

Eric Felt

Markian Tarasiuk

Mrs. Nielsen

Barbara Wallace

Ricky Moreno

Andres Soto

Kenneth Soaper

Warren Abbott

Older Aiden / Storyteller

Rory Culkin

Liam

Graham Verchere

Old Man

Christopher Heyerdahl

Aiden

Kesler Talbot

Older Liam

Reece Thompson

Mallory

Lulu Wilson

Azalea

Erica Tremblay

Sara

Elizabeth Reaser

Tom

Warren Christie

Frank

William B. Davis

Ghost Girl (Lucy Anna)

Grace Sunar

Host

Kyle Jespersen

Cowboy

Murf James

Bartender

Robert Corness

Isabelle

Kayla Deorksen

Townsperson

Troy Anthony Young

Angry Joe

Todd Mann

Creepy boy

Luciano Leroux

Young Hannah

Madeline Hirvonen

Sheriff

Marci T. House

Mother

Katie Stuart

Nurse

Leah Hennessey