Heather
Rachel Brosnahan
David
Travis Fimmel
Brandon Boyd
Asa Butterfield
Bitsy
Christina Ricci
Andy
John Marshall Jones
Kyle
Colin Ford
Susan
Ming-Na Wen
Sheriff Stallings
Karen Allen
Logan
Victoria Justice
Simon
Jacob Batalon
Ashley Whitmore, III
Alex Fitzalan
Sebastian
James Ransone
Amelia / Amelia (voice)
Thailey Roberge
Megan
Emily Hampshire
Dale
Donavon Stinson
Maria Vazquez
Danay Garcia
Lindstrom
Joshua Mikel
Scott Wilke
Greyston Holt
Pigtails
Brea St. James
Bobby Wu
Dan Ginnane
The Prisoner
Lisa Chandler
Hannah
Taissa Farmiga
Blake
Ron Livingston
David Freeman
Drew Tanner
Kyle Wilson
Nick Purcha
Eric Felt
Markian Tarasiuk
Mrs. Nielsen
Barbara Wallace
Ricky Moreno
Alexander Soto
Kenneth Soaper
Warren Abbott
Older Aiden / Storyteller
Rory Culkin
Liam
Graham Verchere
Old Man
Christopher Heyerdahl
Aiden
Kesler Talbot
Older Liam
Reece Thompson
Mallory
Lulu Wilson
Azalea
Erica Tremblay
Sara
Elizabeth Reaser
Tom
Warren Christie
Frank
William B. Davis
Ghost Girl (Lucy Anna)
Grace Sunar
Host
Kyle Jespersen
Cowboy
Murf James
Bartender
Robert Corness
Isabelle
Kayla Deorksen
Townsperson
Troy Anthony Young
Angry Joe
Todd Mann
Creepy boy
Luciano Leroux
Young Hannah
Madeline Hirvonen
Sheriff
Marci T. House
Mother
Katie Stuart
Nurse
Leah Hennessey