Frankie/Vincent Martino

James Franco

Candy

Maggie Gyllenhaal

Larry Brown

Gbenga Akinnagbe

C.C.

Gary Carr

Bobby Dwyer

Chris Bauer

Abigail 'Abby' Parker

Margarita Levieva

Paul Hendrickson

Chris Coy

Chris Alston

Lawrence Gilliard Jr.

Donna 'Darlene' Pickett

Dominique Fishback

Lori

Emily Meade

Rudy Pipilo

Michael Rispoli

Andrea Martino

Zoe Kazan

Reggie Love

Black Thought

Tommy Longo

Daniel Sauli

Sandra Washington

Natalie Paul

Rodney

Method Man

Melissa

Olivia Luccardi

Shay

Kim Director

Harvey Wasserman

David Krumholtz

Dorothy 'Ashley' Spina

Jamie Neumann

Barbara

Kayla Foster

Big Mike

Mustafa Shakir

Danny Flanagan

Don Harvey

Loretta

Sepideh Moafi

Bernice

Andrea-Rachel Parker

Black Frankie

Thaddeus Street

Ruby 'Thunder Thighs'

Pernell Walker

Detective Grossman

Brian Muller

Ace

Clarke Peters

Detective Haddix

Ralph Macchio

Inspector Deputy McDonagh / Capt. Peter McDonagh

Ed Moran

Kim

James Saito

James Waterston

Gene Goldman

Luke Kirby

Rochelle

Ngozi Jane Anyanwu

Waitress

Liz Stauber

Leon

Anwan Glover

Louis

John B. McCann

Ellen

Amber Skye Noyes

Gentle Ritchie

Matthew James Ballinger

Todd Lang

Aaron Dean Eisenberg

Irene

Roberta Colindrez

Adam

Finn Robbins

Carlos

Gino Vento

Joan / Adam

Carolyn Mignini

Jocelyn

Genevieve Hudson-Price

Jersey

Kevin Breznahan

Fran Dwyer

Diana Bologna

Carolee Carmello

George

Ari Kappatos

Kiki Rains

Alysia Reiner

Joey Dwyer

Michael Gandolfini

Juliet

Dena Tyler

John Mariano

Lynda

Franca Vercelloni

Mental Patient

David Johnson

Rizzi

Michael Kostroff

Dominick

Lou Martini Jr.

Christina Fuego

Kat Cunning

Stu

Russell Posner

NYU Student

Jacqueline Honulik

Sam

Daryl Edwards

Teamster

Peter Claymore

Matty 'The Horse' Ianniello / Matty 'The Horse'

Garry Pastore

Rico

Tommy Buck

Clifford

Patrick Gallo

Alan

Ted Sutherland

Julito

Esteban Carmona

Kenneth

Michael Stahl-David

Dave Hiller

Sebastian Arcelus

Marty Hodas

Saul Stein

Cecilia

Maren Lord

Greg Taylor

Ryan Farrell

Lance

Robbie Tann

Carmine Patriccia

James Ciccone

Mug 2

Giovanni Rosselli

Shana

Larisa Polonsky

John

Kevin D. McGee

Lieutenant Gerald Sweeney

Shaun O'Hagan

Terese

Tamzin Brown

Russell

Jim Parrack

Hank Jaffe

Corey Stoll

Vinny 'The Chin' Gigante

John Dinello

Adam

Mikey Moughan

Older man in telephone booth

Jose Duval

Fat Mooney

E.J. Carroll

Car Driver

Paul Heckmann

Tiffany

Danielle Burgess

Cab Driver

Frank Holley

Al Polite

Richard Prioleau

Reggie 'Reg' Winhorn

Calvin Leon Smith

Officer Jeanty

Michael Wren Gucciardo

Times Square Patron

Michael D. Joseph

Port Authority Patron

Ronnie Magri

Greg

Brian McCarthy

Anita

Andrea Pimentel

Park Goer

Doris McCarthy

Lois

Danielle Alfredo

Businessman

Martin R Mlodozeniec

Jennifer Preston

Kelcy Griffin