Host
Joel McHale
Judge
Curtis Stone
Self - Judge
Yolanda Gampp
Self - Contestant
Amanda Carter
Contestant
Natalie Collins-Fish
Self - Contestant
T Lawrence-Simon
Contestant
Jay Clifton
Self - Contestant
Fadi Odeh
Contestant
Thuy-Linh Carroll
Self - Contestant
Amber Croom
Contestant
Carolyn Tunon
Self - Contestant
Yassmeen Haskins
Contestant
Caroline Schmidt
Self - Contestant
Laissa Forlini
Contestant
Cathy Jacobson
Self - Contestant
Camille Marion
Self - Contestant
Thomas McCurdy
Self - Contestant
Luis Flores
Contestant
Nathan Winner
Contestant
Anthony Silvestri
Contestant
Erinn Roth
Self - Contestant
Leslie Milton
Self - Contestant
Lorie Burcham
Self - Contestant
Cory Powell
Self - Contestant
Jason Burcham
Self - Contestant
Donte Fassett
Contestant
Natasha Babchak
Self - Contestant
Kristy Gardner
Contestant
Anthony Damelio
Self - Contestant
Tarsha Joyner
Contestant
Rebecca Miller
Contestant
Jean Plumley
Self - Contestant
Shania Thomas-Floyd
Self - Contestant
Emma Rosenthal
Contestant
Hope Marrero
Self - Contestant
Steph Hsu
Self - Contestant
Sin Yi Cherry Lau
Self - Contestant
Sherry Mach
Self - Contestant
Sally Mach
Guest
Aarón Sánchez
Self - Contestant
Kathleen Regelman
Self - Contestant
Hannah Reyes
Self - Contestant
Enrique Saucedo
Self - Contestant
David Thomas