Joe Toy

Nick Robinson

Patrick Keenan

Gabriel Basso

Biaggio

Moisés Arias

Frank Toy

Nick Offerman

Mrs. Keenan

Megan Mullally

Heather

Alison Brie

Kelly

Erin Moriarty

Mr. Larson

Craig Cackowski

Captain Davis

Mary Lynn Rajskub

Mr. Keenan

Marc Evan Jackson

Colin

Eugene Cordero

Track Suit

William Sonnie

Paul

Nathan Keyes

Aaron

Austin Abrams

Grandma Keenan

Priscilla Kaczuk

Construction Kid

Cristoffer Carter

Carol

Gillian Vigman

Rookie Cop

Thomas Middleditch

Vicki

Lili Reinhart

Italian Man

Paul Floriano

No Sideburns

Brian Sacca

No Sideburns' Friend

Peter Karinen

Bus Passenger

Tony Hale

Bus Driver

Hannibal Buress

Delivery Guy

Kumail Nanjiani

Detective

Jeffrey Grover

Second Detective

Eric Wasserman

Visor

Nicholas Rutherford

Face Paint

Angela Trimbur

Visor

Nick Rutherford

News Reporter

Jennifer Lindgren

Biaggio's Dad

Michael Cipiti

Teen

Justin Cooney

High School Teacher (uncredited)

Christina Cacic

High School Student (uncredited)

Anthony Daniel

Hospital Patient in Wheelchair (uncredited)

Logan Fry

Doctor (uncredited)

Joe Gallipoli

Doctor (uncredited)

David Gragg

Doctor in Plain Clothes (uncredited)

Linda Marie Howell

Track Suit Friend (uncredited)

Cole Kornell

High School Student (uncredited)

Maria Laskowski

Nurse (uncredited)

Derick Mayes

Bus Passenger (uncredited)

Christine McBurney

Bus Passenger (uncredited)

Shawn Michelle

High School Student (uncredited)

Taylor Nelms

Deli Owner (uncredited)

Brady Novak

High School Principal (uncredited)

Joel Thingvall

Paul's Friend (uncredited)

Josh Tippey

Doctor (uncredited)

Nicole Tubbs

Doctor (uncredited)

Lisa Y. Wong

Doctor (uncredited)

Theresa Wylie