Ted Mosby

Josh Radnor

Marshall Erikson

Jason Segel

Lily Aldrin

Alyson Hannigan

Barney Stinson

Neil Patrick Harris

Robin Sherbatsky

Cobie Smulders

Narrator

Bob Saget

Victoria

Ashley Williams

James Stinson

Wayne Brady

Garrison Cootes

Martin Short

Judy Eriksen

Suzie Plakson

Daughter

Lyndsy Fonseca

Sohn

David Henrie

Dr. Soya

Vicki Lewis

Naomi

Katie Holmes

Marvin Eriksen Sr.

Bill Fagerbakke

Grandma Lois

K Callan

Scott

Chase Ellison

Quinn Garvey

Becki Newton

Chester

Michael Gladis

Arvydas

Dimitri Diatchenko

Mickey Aldrin

Chris Elliott

Nora

Nazanin Boniadi

Robin Scherbatsky Sr.

Ray Wise

Patrice

Ellen D. Williams

Ernie Hudson

Ernie Hudson

Rita

Christina Pickles

Architect's Ball Guest

Lynne Alana Delaney

Punchy

Chris Romanski

Morris

Jack Walsh

Pete Durkenson

Jimmi Simpson

Geraldine

Rebecca Creskoff

Kevin Venkataraghavan

Kal Penn

Ranjit

Marshall Manesh

Janet McIntyre

Amber Stevens

Insane Duane

Todd Grinnell

Mrs. Matsen

Renee Taylor

Veronica

Meghan Maureen McDonough

Tracy McConnell

Cristin Milioti

Farrari

Milynn Sarley

Holly

Karissa Vacker

Joe

Caine Sinclair

Doug Martin

Will Sasso

Architect's Ball Guest

Ruben Roberto Gomez

Pilot

Eben Ham

Sheila

Danielle Weeks

King Charles

Jerry Minor

Shop Owner

Anthony Van Epperson

Carl

Joe Nieves

Man in Fez

J. Anthony McCarthy

Sheila

Jamie Denbo

Wendy

Charlene Amoia

Trey

Gregory Michael

Jenni

Melissa Soso

Mia

Eleanor Seigler

Wade Flanagan

Rob Huebel

Chanel

Tara Holt

Consuela

Angela Matemotja

Kate

Nikki Stanley

Sandy RIvers

Alexis Denisof

Loretta Stinson

Frances Conroy

Strip Club Patron

Todd Sandler

Guard 1

Lance Barber

Homeless Man

Paul Eliopoulos

Vance

Jay Acovone

Larry

Ptolemy Slocum

Paula

Rachel Sterling

Erika

Katie Gill

Gary

Bryan Krasner

Kelly

Stefanie Black

Vinny

Guy Nardulli

Sara

Kallee Brookes

Annie

Nicole Andrews

Waitress

Misty Monroe

Kid

Dusan Brown

Robin's Son

Andra Nechita

Milly

Wendy McColm

Nora's Mom

Jacob Witkin

Waiter

Drew Droege

Cab Driver

Max Daniels

Marcus Eriksen

Ned Rolsma

Clive

Duncan Bravo

Larry

Casey Washington

Bridesmaid

Shelli Boone

Guard 2

Ed Alonzo

Butterfly Knife

Matt Lasky

waitress

Erica Handley

Jessica

Nicole Hayden

Gina

Jamie Lea Willett

Kid

Marlowe Peyton

Linsay

Nicole Zeoli

Kismet

Arielle Reitsma

Martin

Ryan Meharry

Yuthers

Bruce Gray

Clay

Anthony Wayne Skeen

Guitar Man

Tahmus Rounds

Marvin Eriksen Jr.

Robert Michael Ryan

Anne

Victoria Geil

Will

Nick Pasqual

Guard 3

Ithamar Enriquez

Young Barney

Riley Thomas Stewart

Maya

Teresa Castillo

Ned

Brendan Robinson

Robyn

Cristen Irene

Serendipity

Elena Diaz

Carol

Kristen Henry King

Plastic Surgery Woman

Tenille Houston

Lauren

Lindsey Morgan

Trick or Treater

Dylan Shea

7-Year-Old Lily Aldrin

Francesca Capaldi

Kelly's Father

Steve Tom

Mr. McIntee

Peter Gannon

Mrs. Venkataraghavan

Sathya Jesudasson

Waitress

Lauren Pritchard

Elderly Chinese Man

Ken Takemoto

Lizbeth

Katy Stoll

Infomercial Actress

Hollie Winnard

Nick

Luka Yovetich

Goatee guy

David Neher

Waitress

Elaine Bartolone

Tina

Chasty Ballesteros

Gina

Nicole Shabtai

Annette

Chelsea Gilligan

Pat

Kevin Wayne Berger

Lauren Halperin

Mr. Drury

Christopher Carroll

Jeff Probst

Jeff Probst

Ronnie

Johnny Giacalone

Nora's Mom

Robin Krieger

Security Guard

Bobby C. King

Parent 1

Adam Tsekhman

Leigh

Christiann Castellanos

Waiter

Mike Nojun Park

Santa Claus

William Mulligan

Lou

Michael G. Coleman

Bus Driver

Mike Grief

Hippie Dude

Dean Chekvala

Zelda

Kelly Connolly

Haley

Michelle Díaz

Wanda

Rachel Bloom

Gerrit Goossen

Darcy

Katherine Von Till

Singer 1

Sy Smith

Randi

Kim Hildago

Nurse

Katie Enright

Punchy's Dad

Vince Cefalu

Paula

Tami Sagher

Fran

Brenda Ballard

Candice

Brandi Burkhardt

Alfred

Elliot Goldwag

Kersten

Tarah Paige

Stella Zinman

Sarah Chalke

Arthur Hobbs

Bob Odenkirk

Leila

Vivian Smallwood

Mike

Ron Nicolosi

Linus

Robert Belushi

Daphne

Sherri Shepherd

Lucy Grafanello

Darcy Rose Byrnes

Nick

Luka Jones

Scooter

David Burtka

Virginia Mosby

Cristine Rose

Stuart

Matt Boren

Nick Podarutti

Michael Trucco

Brad Morris

Joe Manganiello

William Zabka

William Zabka

Producer

Monique Edwards

Bilson

Bryan Callen

Don Frank

Benjamin Koldyke

Gary Blauman / Blauman

Taran Killam

Claudia

Virginia Williams

Becky

Laura Bell Bundy

Alan Thicke

Alan Thicke

Ashley Benson

Abby Elliott

Jason Priestley

James Van Der Beek

Kyle MacLachlan

Bianca Haase