Ted Mosby
Josh Radnor
Marshall Erikson
Jason Segel
Lily Aldrin
Alyson Hannigan
Barney Stinson
Neil Patrick Harris
Robin Sherbatsky
Cobie Smulders
Narrator
Bob Saget
Victoria
Ashley Williams
James Stinson
Wayne Brady
Garrison Cootes
Martin Short
Judy Eriksen
Suzie Plakson
Daughter
Lyndsy Fonseca
Dr. Soya
Vicki Lewis
Naomi
Katie Holmes
Marvin Eriksen Sr.
Bill Fagerbakke
Grandma Lois
K Callan
Scott
Chase Ellison
Quinn Garvey
Becki Newton
Chester
Michael Gladis
Arvydas
Dimitri Diatchenko
Son
David Henrie
Mickey Aldrin
Chris Elliott
Nora
Nazanin Boniadi
Robin Scherbatsky Sr.
Ray Wise
Patrice
Ellen D. Williams
Ernie Hudson
Ernie Hudson
Rita
Christina Pickles
Architect's Ball Guest
Lynne Alana Delaney
Morris
Jack Walsh
Pete Durkenson
Jimmi Simpson
Geraldine
Rebecca Creskoff
Kevin Venkataraghavan
Kal Penn
Ranjit
Marshall Manesh
Janet McIntyre
Amber Stevens
Insane Duane
Todd Grinnell
Mrs. Matsen
Renee Taylor
Punchy
Chris Romanski
Veronica
Meghan Maureen McDonough
Tracy McConnell
Cristin Milioti
Farrari
Milynn Sarley
Holly
Karissa Vacker
Joe
Caine Sinclair
Doug Martin
Will Sasso
Architect's Ball Guest
Ruben Roberto Gomez
Pilot
Eben Ham
Sheila
Danielle Weeks
King Charles
Jerry Minor
Shop Owner
Anthony Van Epperson
Carl
Joe Nieves
Man in Fez
J. Anthony McCarthy
Sheila
Jamie Denbo
Wendy
Charlene Amoia
Trey
Gregory Michael
Jenni
Melissa Soso
Mia
Eleanor Seigler
Wade Flanagan
Rob Huebel
Chanel
Tara Holt
Consuela
Angela Matemotja
Kate
Nikki Stanley
Sandy RIvers
Alexis Denisof
Loretta Stinson
Frances Conroy
Strip Club Patron
Todd Sandler
Guard 1
Lance Barber
Homeless Man
Paul Eliopoulos
Vance
Jay Acovone
Larry
Ptolemy Slocum
Paula
Rachel Sterling
Erika
Katie Gill
Gary
Bryan Krasner
Kelly
Stefanie Black
Vinny
Guy Nardulli
Sara
Kallee Brookes
Annie
Nicole Andrews
Waitress
Misty Monroe
Kid
Dusan Brown
Robin's Son
Andra Nechita
Milly
Wendy McColm
Nora's Mom
Jacob Witkin
Waiter
Drew Droege
Cab Driver
Max Daniels
Marcus Eriksen
Ned Rolsma
Clive
Duncan Bravo
Larry
Casey Washington
Bridesmaid
Shelli Boone
Guard 2
Ed Alonzo
Butterfly Knife
Matt Lasky
waitress
Erica Handley
Jessica
Nicole Hayden
Gina
Jamie Lea Willett
Kid
Marlowe Peyton
Linsay
Nicole Zeoli
Kismet
Arielle Reitsma
Martin
Ryan Meharry
Yuthers
Bruce Gray
Guitar Man
Tahmus Rounds
Marvin Eriksen Jr.
Robert Michael Ryan
Anne
Victoria Geil
Will
Nick Pasqual
Guard 3
Ithamar Enriquez
Young Barney
Riley Thomas Stewart
Maya
Teresa Castillo
Ned
Brendan Robinson
Robyn
Cristen Irene
Serendipity
Elena Diaz
Clay
Anthony Wayne Skeen
Carol
Kristen Henry King
Plastic Surgery Woman
Tenille Houston
Lauren
Lindsey Morgan
Trick or Treater
Dylan Shea
7-Year-Old Lily Aldrin
Francesca Capaldi
Mr. McIntee
Peter Gannon
Mrs. Venkataraghavan
Sathya Jesudasson
Waitress
Lauren Pritchard
Elderly Chinese Man
Ken Takemoto
Lizbeth
Katy Stoll
Infomercial Actress
Hollie Winnard
Nick
Luka Yovetich
Goatee guy
David Neher
Waitress
Elaine Bartolone
Tina
Chasty Ballesteros
Gina
Nicole Shabtai
Annette
Chelsea Gilligan
Pat
Kevin Wayne Berger
Mr. Drury
Christopher Carroll
Jeff Probst
Jeff Probst
Ronnie
Johnny Giacalone
Nora's Mom
Robin Krieger
Security Guard
Bobby C. King
Parent 1
Adam Tsekhman
Leigh
Christiann Castellanos
Waiter
Mike Nojun Park
Santa Claus
William Mulligan
Lou
Michael G. Coleman
Bus Driver
Mike Grief
Hippie Dude
Dean Chekvala
Zelda
Kelly Connolly
Haley
Michelle Díaz
Parent 2
Lauren Halperin
Wanda
Rachel Bloom
Darcy
Katherine Von Till
Singer 1
Sy Smith
Finnish Guy
Gerrit Goossen
Randi
Kim Hildago
Nurse
Katie Enright
Kelly's Father
Steve Tom
Paula
Tami Sagher
Fran
Brenda Ballard
Candice
Brandi Burkhardt
Punchy's Dad
Vince Cefalu
Alfred
Elliot Goldwag
Kersten
Tarah Paige
Stella Zinman
Sarah Chalke
Arthur Hobbs
Bob Odenkirk
Leila
Vivian Smallwood
Mike
Ron Nicolosi
Linus
Robert Belushi
Daphne
Sherri Shepherd
Lucy Grafanello
Darcy Rose Byrnes
Scooter
David Burtka
Virginia Mosby
Cristine Rose
Stuart
Matt Boren
Nick Podarutti
Michael Trucco
Brad Morris
Joe Manganiello
William Zabka
William Zabka
Producer
Monique Edwards
Bilson
Bryan Callen
Don Frank
Benjamin Koldyke
Gary Blauman / Blauman
Taran Killam
Claudia
Virginia Williams
Becky
Laura Bell Bundy
Alan Thicke
Alan Thicke
Ashley Benson
Abby Elliott
Jason Priestley
James Van Der Beek
Kyle MacLachlan
Bianca Haase